SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Peter Dierks who wrote (705205)9/30/2005 6:31:31 PM
From: Thomas A Watson  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 769670
 
Hey I think this should be called, "The New Liberal Creationists"

The Movie: Ronnie Earle, on a Mission from God
The Texas DA is inspired by the Bible to prosecute Tom DeLay.

A new film featuring Travis County, Texas prosecutor Ronnie Earle as he pursued the investigation that led to the indictment of House Majority Leader Tom DeLay portrays Earle less as a partisan figure than as a messianic leader on a mission to rid American politics of the "evil" influence of money.

A copy of the still-unfinished film, entitled The Big Buy, was obtained by National Review Online Friday.

On several occasions in the film, Earle engages in monologues on what he believes is the sinister effect of money in politics. "The root of the evil of the corporate and large-monied interest domination of politics is money," Earle says as he takes the filmmakers on a nighttime drive around Austin. "This is in the Bible. This isn't rocket science. The root of all evil truly is money, especially in politics. People talk about how money is the mother's milk of politics. Well, it's the devil's brew. And what we've got to do, we've got to turn off the tap."

In another scene, Earle describes how he deals with offenders in cases like the campaign-finance investigation. "It's important that we forgive those who come to us in a spirit of contrition and the desire for forgiveness. That's important. But if they don't, then God help them." The film then dissolves to a picture of DeLay.

In yet another scene, Earle describes corporate political contributions, which are illegal in Texas (although state law allows corporations to fund the administrative activities of political action committees) as a problem that is "every bit as insidious as terrorism."

The film also features footage that illustrates the extraordinary access to the DeLay investigation that Earle granted filmmakers Mark Birnbaum and Jim Schermbeck. The Big Buy contains footage of the empty Travis County grand-jury room, as well as video of grand-jury staffers and some members of the grand jury entering the room (the face of one grand juror was obscured by the filmmakers). The film also contains footage of the original indictments of DeLay's associates, as well as those of several corporations, being sorted and copied, apparently before they were made public, on September 21, 2004, the day the indictments were handed up. There is also footage of Earle meeting with his staff attorneys, reading the indictments before they were released. "It's like that moment right after the missiles are launched," Earle says of the scene, "when it's real quiet, but it's not going to be quiet for long."

In the picture, Earle explains that he believes he bears a profound responsibility to alert the American public to the dangers of big political contributions. "I feel great pressure to get the information to the public, to point, to set a tone and to point a direction, and to say which hill needs to be taken," he explains. "When a powerful politician [Earle was referring to DeLay] can demand $25,000 for face time for large monied interests, I mean, something's wrong. What happened to face time for John and Jane Citizen who are raising two kids and they've got two jobs a piece and the kids don't have insurance? What about face time for them and the problems they're facing? Those are the problems that the country is facing."

The film features commentary from a number of DeLay critics, including Lou Dubose, author of The Hammer: Tom DeLay: God, Money, and the Rise of the Republican Congress, columnist Molly Ivins, defeated political rival Martin Frost, Craig McDonald of Texans for Public Justice, and others. It also contains interviews with some Republican state lawmakers in Texas and attorneys for the defendants in the case (DeLay himself declined to cooperate with the filmmakers).

At one point in the picture, Rosemary Lemberg, an assistant district attorney in Earle's office, explains that Earle singlehandedly pushed forward the DeLay investigation over the objections of colleagues. "Ronnie was the only person in maybe a group of six or seven lawyers in a room who thought we ought to go ahead and investigate and look at those things," Lemberg says. "We got sued every time we turned around, we got taken to court over this, and Ronnie was the one who just kept pushing forward with it, and saying 'I'll put more resources on this, just keep hacking at it.'"

Though the film's tone is admiring, the filmmakers allow Earle's critics to suggest that, given the sometimes highly politicized nature of his opinions, he should perhaps work in some field other than law enforcement. "The problem that Ronnie has is that he sees something that he believes is wrong," says Roy Minton, an attorney for one of the organizations investigated by Earle. "If you ask him, when he says, 'They're doing this' and 'They're doing that,' you say, 'Alright, let's assume they're doing that, Ronnie, is that against the law?' He will say it's wrong. You say, 'Well, OK, let's assume that it's wrong. Where is it that it is against the law?'"

nationalreview.com



To: Peter Dierks who wrote (705205)10/1/2005 1:16:41 AM
From: paret  Respond to of 769670
 
Earle's role in DeLay probe called 'scripted'
October 1, 2005
washtimes.com
AUSTIN, Texas (AP) -- The Texas district attorney who brought the criminal case against House Majority Leader Tom DeLay gave a movie crew behind-the-scenes access during the investigation -- proof, Mr. DeLay's defenders say, that Ronnie Earle is trying to make headlines for himself.
"It proves that Ronnie Earle's determination to move ahead with a baseless case was scripted from Day One," said Ben Porritt, Mr. DeLay's spokesman in Washington.
Independent filmmakers Mark Birnbaum and Jim Schermbeck said the Travis County district attorney and his staff gave them some interviews but did not give them access to any of the secret grand jury proceedings or let them witness any of the staff's deliberations in the DeLay investigation.
Mr. DeLay was charged earlier this week with conspiring to illegally funnel corporate campaign contributions to Republican candidates for the Texas Legislature. Texas law bans the use of corporate money for direct campaign expenditures.
The charge forced Mr. DeLay to step aside from his post as the No. 2 Republican in the U.S. House.
Mr. Earle's office declined to comment on the access given to the filmmakers.
Mr. DeLay's supporters said the documentary, "The Big Buy," is part of a pattern of headline-grabbing by Mr. Earle since he began his election probe.
Long before the indictment, Mr. DeLay defenders had said Mr. Earle, a Democrat, was on a witch hunt and was seeking national publicity with his campaign-finance probe.
Mr. Earle made appearances in connection with the investigation on "60 Minutes" and PBS' "Now" and has been profiled by Time and Esquire magazines and various other news organizations.
The access given to the filmmakers "clearly shows Ronnie Earle had ulterior motives. Not only was he out for partisan gain, he was out to promote himself as well," said Carl Forti, spokesman for the National Republican Congressional Committee.
"It kind of indicates Ronnie's proclivities to make a big splash with this," said Dick DeGuerin, Mr. DeLay's attorney.
But Mr. Schermbeck said he and Mr. Birnbaum approached Mr. Earle about the low-budget film two years ago, long before they knew there would be indictments.
"We had to talk him into this," Mr. Schermbeck said.
The film looks at the 2002 elections and the plan by Republicans to win the Texas state House so they could take the unusual step of redrawing congressional districts in the middle of the decade and increase the number of Texas Republicans on Capitol Hill, Mr. Birnbaum said.
Mr. Birnbaum and his partner interviewed some of Mr. Earle's staff and were in Mr. Earle's office with his staff members last year minutes before they walked out to a press conference to announce the first set of indictments in the case, he said.
The filmmakers had already written an ending to the film, but rewrote it when Mr. DeLay was indicted.
"I think it's a more dramatic movie" with Mr. DeLay's indictment, Mr. Schermbeck said. "It makes it more historically important."



To: Peter Dierks who wrote (705205)10/1/2005 9:21:53 AM
From: paret  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 769670
 
In 1993, Mr. Earle staged a high-profile raid on the offices of then-State Treasurer Kay Bailey Hutchison one week after she trounced her Democratic opponent in a special election to fill Lloyd Bentsen's U.S. Senate seat.

As in the DeLay investigation, Mr. Earle won an indictment from a grand jury. Moments before Mrs. Hutchison's trial was to begin, Mr. Earle decided to drop the case. The judge, nonetheless, seated the jury and instructed its members to render a verdict of innocent.

There are more than a few similarities between the Hutchison and DeLay cases: political retribution, months of leaks and innuendo, frivolous charges and a lack of material evidence.

The most surprising aspect of the indictment of Mr. DeLay for violating Texas campaign finance laws -- after three long years of pursuit and six grand juries-- is how devoid of substance it is. If Melville were to float down the Colorado today, he might recognize Captain Ahab in his cabin near the Travis County Courthouse.

And if Cervantes were to ride through Austin, he might wonder why its Don Quixote isn't also tilting at windmills erected by Democrats. Contemporaneous with the transfers between Texans for a Republican Majority and the Republican National Committee for which Mr. DeLay and his associates have been indicted are exchanges between the Texas Democratic Party and the Democratic National Committee that are no less curious.

Mr. Gurwitz is a columnist and member of the editorial board of the San Antonio Express-News.