Not quite what you asked but reletaed..
Tracking the Elusive Hot Spot
Gizmos, Web Sites Claim To Find Wi-Fi Networks; How Well Do They Work?
November 5, 2003
Coffee shops, airports, restaurants and other establishments have been setting up Wi-Fi wireless Internet connections, or "Wi-Fi hot spots," for quite some time now. That's exciting news for anyone with a Wi-Fi ready laptop, because you can just stroll into these places and get onto the Internet, for a fee, or even in some cases free. The problem is finding the hot spots. Wi-Fi locations aren't well advertised, and there's no universal sign or symbol identifying them.
Occasionally, you'll see a sign in a coffee-shop window, like the T-Mobile signs that are posted in many Starbucks branches. But for the most part, wireless hunting is luck of the draw. I often arrive in an airport and have to take out my laptop, boot it up and then let my computer tell me if a Wi-Fi network is present.
To see if we could take some of the guesswork out of this wireless trial and error, my assistant Katie Boehret and I tested two methods of finding Wi-Fi hot spots: Web sites that let you search for locations and a device that "sniffs" for Wi-Fi and notifies you when a signal is near.
This device, the Kensington Wi-Fi Finder, costs $29.99 and seems like it would come in handy for those of us who have to rely on our computers to tell us when Wi-Fi is present. Unfortunately, the Wi-Fi Finder flunked too many of our tests.
The silver-colored Wi-Fi Finder measures the size of a credit card, but a bit thicker, and has a button and three lights on one side. When you press the button, the device is supposed to detect Wi-Fi hot spots within 200 feet. When it finds a hot spot, one, two or all three of its lights glow green according to the signal's strength. If no hot spots can be detected, one red light glows.
Katie tried the Finder on her porch, where her laptop detects a "very low" Wi-Fi signal from a neighbor's wireless network. About five seconds after she pressed its button, two green lights glowed, meaning that it interpreted the signal as one of medium strength. That was a little exaggerated, but still pretty useful.
Then she tested the Finder at a Starbucks near our office, and the device glowed red, despite the fact that multiple laptop users were tapped into the shop's T-Mobile wireless network. I tried it at a different Wi-Fi-equipped Starbucks miles away and got only a red light or a single green one, even when I was inside the store.
I tested the Wi-Fi Finder in my office and at home, where I have two different kinds of Wi-Fi gear -- Apple at work, Windows at home. Despite their branding, both of these networks are instantly recognizable to any laptop within a couple of hundred feet. Windows laptops have no trouble with the Apple network at my office, and Apple laptops have no trouble with the Windows network in my house.
But the Kensington gadget was clueless about them. It showed a red light or an intermittent green light at distances well short of its advertised 200-foot range. Only when I was practically on top of the wireless transmitters in both locations did the Wi-Fi Finder show an unmistakable detection signal. We cannot recommend the Wi-Fi Finder.
Next, Katie tried out a few popular Web sites that claim to help you locate Wi-Fi hot spots in your neighborhood.
Some of these Web sites, such as FreeHotSpots.com and WiFiFreeSpot.com, were created specifically for finding free wireless hot spots. The term "free" usually means that the network was set up by an individual who wants to share.
We logged onto the WiFiFreeSpot.com site and found free networks listed in every state except South Dakota. In addition, hot spots around the world were listed, including some in Canada, Europe and Asia. We selected our home town of Washington, D.C., and found seven free hot spots listed alongside corresponding addresses and phone numbers and, in some cases, Web sites of the hot spots' operators. To test WiFiFreeSpot.com's accuracy, Katie visited two of the listed coffee shops, bought a couple of chai lattes, and a minute later was checking her e-mail.
Another site, HotSpotList.com, lists all hot spots in your area, not just the free ones, though those are listed as well. This site has a section that lets you type in your exact address to search for nearby spots, but when Katie typed in her home address and our office address, nothing came up.
Instead, we used the "browse by region" method. Our search of Washington, D.C., retrieved 63 hot spots, including the ones we had checked out from WiFiFreeSpot. The "Networks" section tells you which of several big commercial Wi-Fi networks each hot spot is using -- such as Boingo, Wayport and T-Mobile. Five of the 63 spots listed on HotSpotList.com were listed as "Independent," meaning they don't require a fee.
But the most comprehensive Wi-Fi locator Web site that we tested was Intel's intel.com/go/hotspots site. If you can ignore the plethora of advertisements for Intel's new Centrino chip set, you'll find this search engine quite useful.
After you type in your specific address, a list of nearby hot spots is retrieved. The list displays the provider and pricing information for each location, as well as details on how to register for the service at that spot. Intel found over 100 hot spots within a 10-mile radius of Katie's apartment, including the two we had spot-checked for accuracy.
Both WiFiFreeSpot.com and HotSpotList.com allow anyone to submit a hot spot for the site by filling out a brief form that asks questions about the location. They do not guarantee the accuracy of the listings, but claim that user feedback helps weed out any nonworking spots.
So, next time, instead of wondering if your local hangout is Wi-Fi equipped, just look it up. |