To: russwinter who wrote (52739 ) 2/7/2006 3:14:12 AM From: shades Respond to of 110194 Abramoff and Rent-Seeking Arnold Kling econlog.econlib.org In a long article filled with details, Fred S. McChesney writes Lobbyists are free to petition government on behalf of clients. Indeed, the process is protected by the First Amendment. Accepting money for the exercise of one's First Amendment rights is not forbidden, either. (Abramoff's biggest legal problems essentially concern tax evasion and defrauding his clients, not creating or extracting their rents.) You have to read the whole article to appreciate the intricacies of the regulation of Indian casinos, and the rent-seeking incentives thereby created.econlib.org For Indian tribes, the good news is that, in the federal government, they have a potential ally in their negotiations with the state over the establishment and operation of tribal casinos. The bad news, however, is that three-cornered negotiations among the tribes, the states and the federal government mean that it is never clear in advance who will be able to do what. As economist Ron Johnson summarizes, there are too many claimants for the right to allow and regulate tribal casinos. Property rights are unclear, and so every side has an incentive to produce the outcome it favors. Tribes want to open profitable casinos, states want to regulate and maximize their tax revenues, and the federal government, at least initially, wants to mediate between the two other interests. In such convoluted situations, particularly with the profits from Indian gambling being so high, Indian tribes have a great incentive to find those who know the game when it comes to state and federal governments.2 Enter lobbyists like Jack Abramoff. Time and again the problem is not the ethics of a weak human - but the power of the RING and destroying the RING is the only way to get people to stop gunning for it. Ron Paul has been preaching it for years now. You dont fundamentally change government by buying shiny metal as the depression ERA goldbugs learned the hard way - there are votes, and watchdogs, and decentralization of power.