To: ChinuSFO who wrote (18218 ) 5/10/2006 3:00:07 PM From: TimF Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 543200 I don't think that there will be a big push by other countries to get involved in the rebuilding unless the security situation improves. If the US military leaves than I think the security situation will get worse. Rebuilding and political solutions are of course crucial but you have to secure the country. I don't think any likely "international peace keeping force" is likely to be up to the job. The history of such forces suggest that they can monitor a peace but usually not create one by force, or enforce one against parties that don't watch peace. Arguably the Balkans might be an exception, but those operations where under NATO control not the UN or some multi-national Arab group, and they included US forces. Other exceptions could probably be found, but in most of them the warring forces where weak and/or exhausted. I feel that it should not be restricted to NATO but also include Arab armies, armies from Muslim countries such as Pakistan, Indonesia etc. NATO countries aren't going to increase their troop commitment, esp. if the US pulls out, but even if we stay. If we pull out its likely that every other country currently providing forces would also pull out. Muslim countries might provide soldiers if the US wasn't there and if the situation was better, but I don't think they are likely to provide significant forces in the current situation, and I think things would be worse if the US pulled out, making them even more reluctant to provide significant forces. Also none of the Muslim countries have militaries that approach the effectiveness or the US military. In theory they could make up for their relative lack of training and equipment and general quality with numbers and the fact that the Arab contingent would no the language. In practice I don't think that will happen. I consider any significant additional force unlikely, one that significantly outnumbered the current American contingent. If 20,000 soldiers could do the job, you might get 20k. Your not going to get 200k, and since 20k wouldn't be seen as enough your not going to even get the 20k. Tim