To: Hope Praytochange who wrote (741750 ) 5/31/2006 11:53:02 PM From: DuckTapeSunroof Respond to of 769670 Bush vows to punish Haditha crime, Iraqis angry By Alastair Macdonald Wed May 31, 3:12 PM ETnews.yahoo.com President George W. Bush vowed on Wednesday to punish any U.S. Marine guilty of shooting Iraqi civilians at Haditha but Iraqis, including the prime minister, complain that U.S. troops have killed elsewhere with impunity. "There is a thorough investigation going on. If ... laws were broken there will be punishment," Bush said in Washington. It was his first public comment on a scandal that some commentators are comparing to the 1968 My Lai massacre in Vietnam that helped turn many Americans against that war. In the latest instance where Iraqis say U.S. forces have shed innocent blood, relatives and Iraqi police and army officers in Samarra, north of Baghdad, told Reuters U.S. troops killed three unarmed civilians, including a 60-year-old woman and a mentally handicapped man, in their home three weeks ago. A U.S. spokesman said only three guerrillas were killed. The Pentagon has limited comments on Haditha to anonymous briefings. Last week an official said charges including murder were possible following a military investigation into the deaths of 24 civilians in the violent western town of Haditha on November 19. An official repeated on Wednesday that an initial investigation found evidence Marines killed the civilians and that forensic reports of bullet wounds contradicted the troops' statements that 15 of the dead were killed by an insurgent bomb. Widespread leaks from U.S. lawmakers briefed on the case and from lawyers defending those under suspicion tend to back up accusations from Iraqis who say Marines shot dead 24 people in three houses and a car in a killing spree sparked by the death of a comrade in a roadside bombing during a dawn patrol. "IN COLD BLOOD" John Murtha, an opposition Democratic congressman and former Marine, said troops "killed innocent civilians in cold blood" and called Haditha a bigger setback to U.S. hopes for ensuring a friendly Iraq than the Abu Ghraib prison abuse scandal of 2004. Iraqis themselves, inured to what they believe are routine American abuses, have reacted less. Though keen for an end to occupation, many see U.S. troops contributing to security. U.S. military officials admitted several months ago that no civilians were killed in the roadside bombing, as originally stated in a military statement. They have concurred with doctors at Haditha's hospital who told Reuters in March that they had signed death certificates saying all 24 were shot. One was a child of three. Survivors' testimonies and video provided by an Iraqi human rights organization indicate a few Marines went from house to house killing men, women and children. A human rights activist said U.S. lawmakers were shown photographs of some corpses indicating they were kneeling when shot. "They shot at all of us. I pretended I was dead," said Safa Younis, 12, the only one of her family of eight to survive, in a video provided to Reuters by the Hammurabi Human Rights group. Questions about a cover-up have focused on why Marines said civilians were killed by a bomb when Marine investigators had already photographed the scene on the day. Relatives of those other troops have told U.S. media they were traumatized by the experience of moving bodies, including a child shot in the head. Thaer al-Hadithi of the Hammurabi group told Reuters the U.S. military paid relatives $2,500 for 15 of the dead within "a few weeks." A U.S. officer told U.S. media this week he paid out $38,000. Other victims were considered enemy fighters. Hadithi said he believed payments were made before the U.S. military in Baghdad began to look into the incident in January, prompted by a local video handed to Time magazine reporters. PRIME MINISTER Three Marine officers, a lieutenant colonel and two captains, were relieved of command. U.S. media reports suggest a dozen Marines led by a sergeant face the most serious suspicions. Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, keen to show Iraqis a leader in full control for the first time since Saddam Hussein, wants investigations into Haditha and other cases: "There is a limit to the acceptable excuses," he told Reuters on Tuesday. Iraq's new ambassador to Washington, Samir al-Sumaidaie, has complained that Marines killed his young cousin near Haditha last July and said on Tuesday he was not satisfied with a U.S. finding that he was killed in self-defence. He also said he believed U.S. troops had killed other civilians in the area. "It is absolutely imperative that we remove the bad apples and we expose them and we don't try to cover them up," he said. Iraqis have long complained that soldiers kill civilians in raids on rebels or at checkpoints. Police said two women, one pregnant, were shot dead by U.S. troops in Samarra on Tuesday. Rarer but not unknown are accusations that soldiers have killed wantonly. In March, the military said it was looking at police allegations U.S. soldiers killed 11 people, including five children, found bound in a house at Ishaqi, near Samarra. U.S. military spokesmen have been unable to give an answer this week as to the status of that investigation. John Sifton of Human Rights Watch said of the Haditha affair: "What would be a new phenomenon on the ground would be for Iraqis to see the U.S. really taking this seriously." (Additional reporting by Will Dunham and Caren Bohan in Washington) Copyright © 2006 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Copyright © 2006 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.