To: Dexter Lives On who wrote (53148 ) 7/4/2006 12:19:00 PM From: Dexter Lives On Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 197225 For those under the illusion that Intel shut down IEEE 802.20 Mobile-Fi:ieee802.org Motorola & Samsung shut it down. The real powerhouses behind WiMAX are starting to show their hands. Intel was, and will continue to be, nothing more than a powerful adopter.... Tom Morrow1.0 Summary Response: The appeal panel’s interpretation regarding the issue of approval threshold for the TSP was based on the meeting minutes of 802.20. Mr. Upton provided a reference that indicates the type of vote (procedural) was announced at the start of the session. The panel is open to a re-hearing or an agreement between the parties on that one narrow question. The appeal panel submits this response to Mr. Upton’s rehearing request because some of the arguments noted pertain to procedures that the panel believes it appropriately followed. If the EC believes the procedures (e.g., conducting closed deliberations, and issuing a clarification when requested and with no objection from the other party) were inappropriate, the panel requests that the EC provide clear guidance. Other than the narrow question noted above, the panel believes that there is no justification for a rehearing. If the EC determines that rehearing is appropriate, the Panel is, of course, prepared to reconvene in accordance with that decision and any guidance that it includes. In determining the appropriate relief, the Panel took into consideration the timing of further proceedings in 802.20. The Panel suggests that the EC arrange that any rehearing granted be completed by 1 PM on July 17, 2006 (Monday of the next Plenary Session). Any later time for completion of the rehearing would impact implementation of the Appeal Panel’s recommended remedy.