To: Dave Budde who wrote (54776 ) 7/21/2006 3:03:08 PM From: inaflash Respond to of 213182 What system(s) does your new MBP replace, a PC, Mac or both? And if the MBP didn't exist (and Macs didn't run Windows), what would have been your replacement systems(s)? No, I'm your quintessential Mac user, though I am unfortunately well versed in Windows. The MBP replaced a Powermac G4. And it's convincing me to run Windows, not to run from it. This strategy will backfire. I bet it will convert more Mac users to Windows long term than the other way around. If it didn't exist, I would have not replaced it until something better came along. Don't get me wrong. I love Apple computers. I love OS X. I loath Windows. But it's not a slam dunk that Apple will grow it's computer market share. If the stock does well, and I hope it does, it won't be from computer sales Thanks for answering your specific situation. I wanted to know if you were a Mac user who's switching to Windows or a Windows user switching to Mac or a dual user. I presume you use a Windows system elsewhere as well, but I'll throw you into the first category. For the Mac users switching to Windows, you wind up minimally affecting Apple market share, since you stuck with Apple hardware. The real loss will come if Mac users head to HP and Dell hardware. In my view, many have already done so, and these new Intel Macs don't really change the equation. The second group of Windows users switching to Mac do affect Apple market share to the positive. I believe the number of such users is more than most people are projecting. These users may be running OSX or Windows, but the fact they're running on Apple hardware is the significant change. Going from 6% to 12% market share this quarter is a great example, and I think they're going up from here. Lastly the dual use group now owns at least one Mac and one Windows system. They'll either be so turned off by one or the other and abandon that system, or they'll go to a new unit that can run both OS, and again, we're talking Apple hardware. I've been saying this ever since BootCamp came out, which is it doesn't matter what OS people run as long as it's on Apple hardware. In the mid range and high end, Apple hardware alone is quite compelling, and you get OSX thrown in for free. macworld.com It's a relatively older article, but you can find more recent comparisons. The point is that they're generally comparable and if you like the tradeoffs, it's something to consider, and I believe that it's showing up in the sales.