To: Brumar89 who wrote (51094 ) 9/13/2006 1:04:06 PM From: J. C. Dithers Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 90947 Very well done, Brumar. Very insightful. Still, it would seem a forlorn hope that the object of your analysis would learn anything from it. You know, the truth is that I have never disliked X. "Dislike" needs an emotional component which just isn't there for me. (Maybe in the same sense that some people--me--think Bill Clinton to be despicable in many ways, but still find him a likable rogue). I've always thought X to be one of the most intriguing personalities on SI. Given that I vehemently disagree with virtually all of her opinions and positions, I have found her to be a worthwhile person to debate. She is quick-witted and articulate, and thus a worthy adversary. I feel that with stakes as high as they are in the current political environment, I for one need the practice one gets from debating skillful adversaries on the opposite extreme. I know X well enough to know that she will only debate a topic to a certain point. Politeness has nothing to do with it. When her point (or mood change)is reached, she abruptly terminates the exchange by an insult ("bigot" being her favorite), or a "don't post to me," or the nuclear option of banishment. I believe she thinks of herself as a very independent thinker, but in reality all of her positions are in lock-step with the gurus of the far left. Thus it is little wonder that she favors censorship and suppression of opposing viewpoints, traditional tactics of the shout-down leftist extremists. For the life of me, I can't get worked up enough to dislike X, let alone hate her. Like Scrooge, her ill temper harms no one so much as herself. I won't be a party to feeling any emotion about her whatsoever. As is the case with you, I only make these public comments about her because she has not once, but twice, chosen to comment about me after banning me.