To: Mr.Creosote who wrote (75840 ) 12/17/2006 9:43:18 AM From: russwinter Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 110194 <always been a poor class> Here's is some data on US income disparity, it's the widest ever. epi.org Don't know if you ever read my blog, but had a through presentation on this rich-poor aspect and the Gini coefficient. It one of the more important blog posts, I've ever written. I don't feel the US is an advanced nation model any more is part of my conclusion.wallstreetexaminer.com So for sake of your "always been a poor class" argument, let's just put them (the bottom quintile) off the radar screen. They are history as far as consumption goes, with only 8% of the US total, just Brazil like subsistence levels. That's not the group I've ever talked about, period. The top quantile is responsible for 39% of US consumption, and as you have suggested, they (or at least most of them), seem to be doing fine?, maybe?, sort of? Up to now, they have been getting better off, as the Bubbles have padded their wallets. So that leaves the middle three quantiles, between 20-80, who are responsible for 53% of US consumption. Is that group doing fine? Maybe? sort of? It's actually those folks that have the big debt serf mortgages, and declining housing, not the very poor. I think the evidence there is getting very clouded, and if there is a big slip underway, it is unlikely the top quantile can hold the fort, unless they can loot the income from somebody: more globalization? more plutocrat friendly tax cuts? more Bubbles to monetize? Maybe find something productive to do besides being parasites or shufffling finance? Or just some how keep this deal making racket goingbloomberg.com news.yahoo.com We agree (from your quote above) that the lowest quantile is history for more of this, and personally I think the second lowest quantile is already Brazili-fried, so who's left? Maybe the 60-80 group can be milked some more, but will be tough. There might also still be some labor to be squeezed and Brazili-fried in the bottom quadrant of the top quantile group I suppose?