Most energy stocks haven't moved much since April or so of last year, when big investors dropped out of the game in anticipation that oil and natural gas prices would level off. This was one instance when conventional wisdom turned out to be correct. After more or less tripling in four years, crude oil prices peaked in the low $70 per barrel range last August and, until last week, were treading water in the $50 to $60 range.
Energy stock investors lost interest, worrying that stagnant energy prices would reduce demand for drilling services, pressure oil producers' profits and otherwise ruin the party. Besides, they had already enjoyed a good run. Most energy-related indexes more than doubled from early 2004 through last spring. Heading higher, long term So, what happens next? Will energy prices resume their uptrend or remain in a trading range?
This is probably obvious, but I'll say it anyhow. Like so many things, energy prices reflect the balance between supply and demand. Prices drop if supply exceeds demand and rise when demand exceeds supply.
While there's no real consensus on the issue, many experts advise that global oil production has more or less peaked. While they sound spectacular when announced, new oil finds, at best, compensate only for the depletion of existing reserves.
World oil usage, already precariously close to the maximum that can be produced, is likely to soar as millions of consumers in China, India and other emerging countries find themselves able to afford automobiles, microwaves, espresso makers and other middle-class luxuries.
Geopolitical tensions, if anything, have worsened in recent months, and it's not far-fetched to speculate that a terrorist strike of political upheaval somewhere in the world could disrupt oil supplies.
If you agree that energy prices are headed up long term, this might be a good time to consider energy-related stocks, especially since most have been in a trading range for almost a year. Narrowing your search I'll use MSN's Deluxe Screener to find energy stock candidates. The screener has a useful feature that allows you to pinpoint particular energy industry subsets of interest, including:
* Independent Oil & Gas * Major Integrated Oil & Gas * Oil & Gas Drilling & Exploration * Oil & Gas Equipment & Services * Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing * Oil & Gas Pipelines
Oil and gas pipeline operators get paid by the volume, not the price, of petroleum products transported. Thus they won't necessarily prosper from rising energy prices, and I didn't search for stocks in that category.
You can see price charts for indexes reflecting the action of each industry subset by selecting Historical Charts, then clicking on Find, Industry Indexes, Other Industry Indexes and finally, Energy. That's worth doing. That's how I learned that most of the industry categories had been in a trading range since April 2006.
However, that was not the case for Major Integrated Oil & Gas, which includes the likes of ExxonMobil (XOM, news, msgs) and Chevron (CVX, news, msgs). Although considerably off its December 2006 peak, the index had moved up last year and didn't fit the "in the doldrums" situation of the other energy industry subsets. Thus, I didn't look for Major Integrated Oil & Gas stocks.
The situation may have changed by the time that you run the screen. So, check the subindustry charts first and avoid any that are in sharp downtrends or have already moved up considerably. You can gauge that by comparing the index to its 200-day moving average. Ideally, you want an index that is more or less straddling its 200-day average, indicating consolidation. Indexes considerably above their moving averages are in strong uptrends and vice versa.
Finding worthwhile energy plays in today's environment requires a different strategy than searching for growth stocks.
Because oil prices shot up so much, most energy stocks enjoyed strong earnings growth in 2006. Since analysts are basing their earnings forecasts on flat oil prices, they're not expecting much, if any, earnings growth this year. Thus, you can't screen based on earnings growth forecasts. Also, since most energy firms are coming off a great year, there's little to gain from screening based on debt levels, profit margins, etc.
Here's my strategy for finding worthwhile energy-stock candidates. First, I ruled out the obvious duds, and then I isolated stocks favored by savvy institutional investors. Then, from that list, I used MSN's StockScouter to pinpoint stocks the strongest stocks, partially based on fundamentals and partially from a charting (technical) perspective.
Here are the details. Pick your sector Start by picking an Industry subset from the Energy category. You can only screen for one Industry subset at a time. For example:
Screening parameter: Industry Name = Oil & Gas Drilling & Exploration
After you've run one screen, select another Industry subset and rerun the screen. No duds My strategy requires mainstream stocks that will move up with their sector when it catches fire. Lightly traded stocks that nobody has heard of don't fit that bill. Most stocks trade hundreds of thousands of shares daily, and that's what we need here.
Screening parameter: Average Daily Trading Volume Last Quarter >= 100,000
Along the same lines, cheap stocks get that way because most market players don't like their fundamental outlook. Since we're looking for strong stocks, not for contrarian or value candidates, we'll do best by sticking with stocks that the market likes. Depending upon the circumstances, stocks trading above $5 per share might fit that bill. However, since we're looking for solid in-favor picks, I set the bar higher at $15.
Screening parameter: Last Price >= 15 Let the big boys do the work Institutional investors such as mutual funds and pension plans have squads of analysts at their beck and call. Don't waste time and effort reinventing the wheel. Stick with stocks that the big boys like. Institutional ownership measures the percentage of a firm's shares held by these wired-in players. The percentage often exceeds 95% and rarely falls below 50% for in-favor stocks.
Screening parameter: % Institutional Ownership >= 50 StockScouter MSN's StockScouter combines dozens of factors such as valuation, earnings growth, recent changes in analyst forecasts, institutional and insider trading and chart action to grade stocks from 1 to 10, where 10 is best. One of StockScouter's strengths is that you can use it to spot the best prospects within a given industry, which is exactly what we want here.
Although, in theory, stocks rated 6 should outperform those rated 2, research has found that stocks rated 8 and above are your best bets to outperform the market over the next six months. However, the ratings depend partially on earnings forecasts. Since analysts are basing their earnings forecasts on energy prices remaining flat while our premise is that oil prices will rise, I've given our stocks a little extra slack and only required a rating of 7 to qualify.
Screening parameter: Rating >=7 Charting the course Since we're trying to get in ahead of the crowd, a stock's price chart action might be our first clue that good news is on the way. That's because market players with access to inside information often accumulate shares ahead of the news.
Thus, in place of a more stringent overall StockScouter rating requirement, I'm putting more emphasis on the StockScouter's technical grade, which analyzes recent price action. Technical grades run from A through F (no E), where A is best. I require a minimum B grade, which, just like in school, is above average.
Screening parameter: Technical Grade >= B
My screens turned up six independent oil and gas producers, two oil and gas refining companies, two oil and gas drilling and exploration companies and three stocks in the oil and gas equipment and services category. However, two of the three oil and gas equipment and service providers listed, Infrasource Services (IFS, news, msgs) and Willbros Group (WG, news, msgs), derive most of their revenues from businesses outside the energy industry. I eliminated them because they would not benefit much from rising energy prices. Here are the remaining 11 candidates:
Company Industry Recent price StockScouterrating StockScoutertechnical grade
XTO Energy (XTO, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
52.57
10
B
Talisman Energy (TLM, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
17.84
9
B
Noble Energy (NBL, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
58.65
10
A
Denbury Resources (DNR, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
30.19
9
B
Cabot Oil & Gas (COG, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
70.57
10
A
Petroleum Development (PETD, news, msgs)
Independent Oil & Gas
52.25
10
A
Valero Energy (VLO, news, msgs)
Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing
58.77
7
B
Murphy Oil (MUR, news, msgs)
Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing
51.72
7
B
Oceaneering International (OII, news, msgs)
Oil & Gas Drilling & Exploration
41.07
9
B
Whiting Petroleum (WLL, news, msgs)
Oil & Gas Drilling & Exploration
45.42
7
B
Lone Star Technologies (LSS, news, msgs)
Oil & Gas Equipment & Services
50.04
9
B
Four of the independent oil and gas firms listed -- Cabot Oil & Gas (COG, news, msgs), Denbury Resources (DNR, news, msgs), Petroleum Development (PETD, news, msgs) and XTO Energy (XTO, news, msgs) -- produce oil and natural gas from resources located primarily within the U.S. Noble Energy (NBL, news, msgs) operates in the U.S., but also has resources in South America, China, the North Sea and in other areas. Talisman Energy (TLM, news, msgs), although headquartered in Canada, is traded on the NYSE and operates in the U.S., Australia and many other countries as well.
My screen listed only two oil and gas refining and marketing companies. Valero Energy (VLO, news, msgs), which specializes in handling difficult-to-refine heavy crude, refines and markets exclusively in the U.S. Murphy Oil (MUR, news, msgs), although listed in the refining and marketing category, also produces oil and natural gas. Murphy operates in Canada, Ecuador, Malaysia and other countries, as well as in the U.S.
Although listed in the oil and gas drilling and exploration category, Whiting Petroleum (WLL, news, msgs) is an independent oil and gas producer, much the same as the firms listed in the independent oil and gas category. Whiting operates primarily in the U.S.
Oceaneering International (OII, news, msgs), also listed under oil and gas drilling and exploration, actually provides services and products to offshore oil and gas drillers.
Finally, Lone Star Technologies (LSS, news, msgs) also provides parts and services to oil drillers and producers. |