To: Eric L who wrote (4697 ) 3/26/2007 5:33:09 PM From: sisuman Respond to of 9255 Goldman-Sachs views on MOT and NOK. Nokia (ADR) (NOK) Communications Technology Mar 07, 2007 Motorola's retreat supports Nokia's margins, at the expense of ASPs WHAT'S CHANGED: We are reducing our Motorola 2007 market share forecast by 350 bp. Motorola’s CEO confirmed at our Tech Conference last week that the company is pursuing a selective strategy in those emerging markets where its lack of scale and distribution breadth prevent it from making money. The CEO cited Africa and Vietnam as two particular examples where Motorola passed on unprofitable contracts during 1Q, likely benefiting Nokia, the market and margin leader in these regions. Remains Buy. IMPLICATIONS: 1) The fact that the industry no.2 is in retreat underscores our confidence in the sustainability of Nokia’s margins in the mid-term. We expect Nokia to gain share until Motorola’s high-end/3G products are refreshed (likely late 2007 at the earliest), allowing Motorola to contemplate costly investment in distribution without damaging its margins. 2) Modest share losses by Motorola were already factored into our Nokia estimates, so we increase our 1Q unit forecast only modestly to 95 mn (37.3% share) from 93 mn, and our 2007 forecast to 428 mn from 418 mn. 3) Incremental units are coming at low ASPs, leading us to cut our 1Q ASP to €87 (versus the SME Direkt consensus of €90). 4) As we highlighted in our February 23 industry report, ‘A tale of two handset markets’, we believe that Nokia’s scale and distribution reach allow it to dominate c.80% of the emerging markets’ profit pool, earning EBIT margins in line with the group average. Nokia’s incremental share gains therefore affect price, not margins. 5) EPS forecasts rise by €0.02 in 2007 to €1.17; our FY08 forecasts are unchanged. VALUATION: We retain our 12-month, DCF-based price target of €20. Sisuman