To: Tenchusatsu who wrote (332714 ) 4/12/2007 1:52:06 PM From: tejek Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 1573095 Ted, > France evolved into revolution because the wealthy were living an incredible lifestyle while the poor were starving. Last time I checked, most Americans were overweight, not starving. Don't you mean Asian Americans.......or have you successfully knocked off the pounds? <g> While there are some people who go to bed hungry at nite in the US, its true that few people starve to death. Having said that, the standards that determine wealth vs poverty in the US have changed considerably since Antoinette's time. People now become angry not because they are starving but rather because they are struggling to keep a roof over their heads while the likes of Paris Hilton ride around in their Bentleys without a clue as to how to put gas into it. Nonetheless, the underlying Antoinette premise is still the same.......there are some who have great wealth and flaunt it in excess while most are struggling to stay afloat. And yes, I too saw the movie. I don't know how you could have missed the sympathetic portrayal of Marie Antoinette as a naive socialite. It's as if the stuffy, aristocratic lifestyle was forced upon her and she couldn't help but find relief in parties and wild spending. At 14, she was the Dauphine of France.....imagine an American teen put into such a position. She was naive. She was put into a bad situation without the skills to deal with it. Over the course of time, she made many enemies. Her worst behavior occurred when she was still a teenager. Unfortunate for her, she became the symbol for all the excesses of the upper classes. While the spending by Antoinette and the upper classes was daunting and hurting France, the real problem was the series of wars involving the country:"There were also wider problems affecting France at the time, for the entire country was standing on the edge of bankruptcy. The long series of wars fought by Louis XIV and Louis XV had left France with the highest national debt in Europe. French society was under-taxed and what little money was collected failed to save the economy. Louis XVI was persuaded by Pierre Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais to support the American revolutionaries in their fight for independence from Britain. This decision was a disaster for France, despite its victory, because the cost was enormous." en.wikipedia.org Its eerie how closely the France of that time parallels the US of this time.Meanwhile, the suffering and the anger of the masses were only mentioned briefly, but never visually portrayed in the movie except in "graffiti" moments. Wasn't the movie from Antoinette's POV?If anything, I wonder if the movie went a little too far in its revisionism of Marie Antoinette's life. Makes me wonder whether the celebrity culture we have these days is starting to rewrite history. When humans become symbols, the traits that reinforce the symbol image tend to get embellished. I think history is trying to rectify the excesses falsely attributed to Antoinette. She was no saint but I don't think she was the devil either.