To: M0NEYMADE who wrote (19067 ) 5/7/2007 12:05:58 AM From: Peter Dierks Respond to of 71588 World Bank Rolls Nearly 1,400 employees make more than Condi Rice. Thursday, May 3, 2007 12:01 a.m. EDT Renaissance Pope Adrian VI once said of the Roman Curia that its sins "were so widespread that those afflicted by the vice did not even notice the stench anymore." It's a line that could also describe the World Bank staff and its outrage over the "scandalous" raise Paul Wolfowitz awarded his girlfriend Shaha Riza when he became president. If it's transparency over salaries that bank employees want, by all means let's have it. Specifically, let's make public the names, salaries and benefits of every bank employee who makes more than Ms. Riza. American taxpayers supply some 17% of the bank's capital, and a new round of fund raising for the bank's International Development Association is about to commence. If Congress is going to ante up the $7 billion or so the bank is expected to request, the least it can do is insist on more accountability. Keep in mind that Mr. Wolfowitz was directed by the bank's ethics committee to find a new job for Ms. Riza, a longtime bank staffer, when he became president in 2005, despite his requests to be recused from the matter. The committee suggested an "in situ promotion" to the next paygrade or an "ad hoc salary increase" as part of a "settlement of claims." The offer was intended to be generous, given that Ms. Riza--who already had been shortlisted for promotion--was being forced out of the bank, possibly for good, for a conflict she did not create and to a job she had not sought. Ms. Riza was eventually given an external assignment at the State Department with a salary (paid by the bank) of $193,000, up from the $133,000 she had previously made at the bank. To Mr. Wolfowitz's critics, this was improper and excessive, especially given that Condoleezza Rice makes about $10,000 less. But this is highly selective outrage given normal procedure at the bank. Of its roughly 10,000 employees, no fewer than 1,396 have salaries higher than the U.S. Secretary of State; clearly "fighting poverty" does not mean taking a vow of poverty at "multilateral" institutions. At the time of Ms. Riza's departure from the bank, she was a Grade "G" (senior professional) employee; the typical salary in that grade hovers around the $124,000 mark. For the next level, Grade "H"--the level to which Ms. Riza was due to be promoted--salaries average in the $170,000 range, with an upper band of $232,360. No fewer than 17% of bank employees are in this happy bracket. Even sweeter, all of this is tax-free to non-Americans. U.S. employees have to pay U.S. tax but have their income taxes reimbursed by the bank. As with any public bureaucracy, these jobs are also impossible to lose for anything other than gross incompetence or venality. Some of Mr. Wolfowitz's accusers--notably, former general counsel Roberto Danino--are angry precisely because he upset their lifetime sinecure by demanding higher performance. These details are common knowledge within the bank itself, so it's only fair that they be made public to the American taxpayers who finance this comfortable poverty-fighting lifestyle. Alison Cave, the head of the bank staff association leading the campaign against Mr. Wolfowitz, ought to be the first to make her salary and performance reviews public--in the name of restoring the bank's "credibility," to borrow one of her favorite words. And while Congress is at it, let's also disclose the names and details of the 193 bank employees with "potential for supervision" conflicts-of-interest cited by the bank's human-resources department in a 2005 document. When Mr. Wolfowitz became president, Ms. Riza was four levels down in the World Bank hierarchy--a far more distant potential conflict, we suspect, than most of those 193 cases. From the beginning, the attack on Mr. Wolfowitz and Ms. Riza has been a calculated political putsch by Europeans and World Bank staff who fancy themselves immune from any real public scrutiny. If it's a "credible" and transparent bank they want, let's get out the firehose and really go to work. opinionjournal.com