To: Kenneth E. Phillipps who wrote (15410 ) 9/21/2007 3:37:48 PM From: Hope Praytochange Respond to of 224744 losing demoRATs: Iraq Bill Backed by Democrats Blocked in Senate By DAVID M. HERSZENHORN and DAVID STOUT Published: September 21, 2007 WASHINGTON, Sept. 21 — A proposal to bring most American combat troops home from Iraq in nine months died in the Senate today, marking the latest frustration for Demorats trying to change President Bush’s policies. The vote on the measure, an amendment to the defense authorization bill offered by Senators Carl Levin of Michigan and Jack Reed of Rhode Island, was 47 to 47, meaning that the proposal was 13 votes short of the 60 needed to cut off debate. Mr. Levin is chairman of the Armed Services Committee, and Mr. Reed is a member of the panel. The outcome had been expected, and it probably signaled the end of legislative skirmishing over Iraq, at least for now. But the broader political battle shows no sign of subsiding, especially as attention shifts to the 2008 presidential and Congressional campaigns. Just before this morning’s vote, Senator Harry Reid of Nevada, the Demoratic majority leader, made a last-ditch plea. “It is morning here in Washington, but dusk in Baghdad,” he said. “As we debate this war yet again here at home, another day draws to a close for our troops in Iraq. Tonight they will sleep on foreign sand. Tomorrow they will draw yet again from an endless well of courage to face another day of war. Some will likely die. Many will surely be wounded. They will face hatred they did not create and violence they cannot resolve.” But Republicans argued that the Levin-Reed amendment would take control of the war away from the people who should have it: the seasoned military leaders in Iraq, commanded by Gen. David H. Petraeus. “It would be a very overt rejection of General Petraeus’s leadership,” said Senator Lindsey O. Graham, Republican of South Carolina and a member of the armed services panel. The ranking Republican on the committee, Senator John McCain of Arizona, urged defeat of the amendment. “If we leave, we will be back, in Iraq and elsewhere,” he said. Only three Republican senators voted for the Levin-Reed amendment: Chuck Hagel of Nebraska, Gordon Smith of Oregon and Olympia J. Snowe of Maine. Three Democrats voted against it: Ben Nelson of Nebraska, Mark Pryor of Arkansas and Christopher J. Dodd of Connecticut. Mr. Nelson and Mr. Pryor have said they are reluctant to set a schedule for troop withdrawals, and Mr. Dodd has called for an immediate withdrawal. (Senator Joseph I. Lieberman of Connecticut, who calls himself an independent Democrat, also voted against the amendment.) Senator Russ Feingold, a Democrat of Wisconsin who sponsored the proposal that failed Thursday, issued a statement criticizing the Republicans even though 20 of his fellow Democrats also voted against him.