To: Knighty Tin who wrote (109218 ) 9/22/2007 11:27:58 AM From: Freedom Fighter Respond to of 132070 KT It doesn't matter when the sell off started. What matters is the extent of the bubble and who it occurred under. It was going to mean revert eventually no matter what. It was built under Clinton/Greenspan/Rubin during the great Wall St Rape and Pillage. That's just the fact. I think cutting dividend taxes and other taxes on capital are both favorable for the economy and the stock market in the long term and short term (assuming they are accompanied by spending cuts). But as I said prior, I'm not a fan of running deficits to stimulate economic activity. I think that works in the short term but is a negative in the long term. I'd rather address the monetary causes of booms and busts by eliminating the Fed and just cope with a downturn in the meantime. All that said, I think any president in the position Bush was in at the time (market crash, 9/11, etc..) would have purposely run deficits. The only difference would have been which taxes they cut, what they spent extra money on, and in what proportions they did each. Those are value judgements. His mistake was in not cutting spending once the economy started to recover. And obviously, going into Iraq was an error both financially and strategically. IMHO, the republicans have the right idea about the idealogical struggle under way, but the strategy decisions are being made by traitors and religious fanatics. The housing bubble certainly helped bail out the economy. I'm not sure how much the policies of the republicans contributed to that. Again, I think that was more of a monetary phenomenon that occurred under his watch for which I mostly blame Greenspan and our monetary system. I blame the Clinton administration a little more for the bubbles under his watch because Rubin was running around the world bailing everyone out with the IMF etc... Sometimes it seemed like the entire administration was geared towards changing stats to makes things look better and promoting an even bigger bubble. But to some extent the seeds were planted in the early 90s banking bailout with all the cheap money that came before him. I'm not a fan of the republicans. I'm a fan of unbiased analysis. I don't have a horse in this race. I am a libertarian that hates both sides for different reasons.