To: Elroy who wrote (247153 ) 11/1/2007 3:54:14 PM From: bentway Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500 As Israel Tightens its Squeeze on Gaza, Where is the Outrage? Palestine Monitorpalestinemonitor.org 1 November 2007 As Israel intensifies its blockade of the Gaza Strip by cutting fuel supplies to one and a half million people, the European Union has exposed its true colours, and wilful ignorance of the facts on the ground. Whilst a dozen Palestinian and Israeli human rights organisations immediately joined forces to issue a joint press release wholeheartedly condemning Israel’s actions, and demanding an injunction against the Israeli Government, the EU took a very different stance. It noted Israel’s decision "with concern," and underlined "the need for carefully weighing the negative impact of such measures on a civilian population already living under very difficult conditions." EU Commissioner for External Relations, Benita Ferrero-Waldner said she would be raising the issue of fuel cuts during meetings with Israeli leaders this week. "I think collective punishment is never a solution" she stated grandly. If the situation in the Gaza Strip were not so desperate, Ms Ferrero-Waldner’s comment would almost be comic. What exactly does she think Israel has been doing to the population of Gaza for these last two years? Since its unilateral "withdrawal" in August 2005, Israel has consistently claimed it is not occupying Gaza. But the facts on the ground speak for themselves. The Israeli military maintains control over all of Gaza’s borders, plus its airspace and territorial waters. Israel dictates who, and what, enters and leaves the Gaza Strip, and has systematically used this power to bully and collectively punish civilians across Gaza. To cite just a few recent examples of Israeli collective punishments: the two main commercial crossings into Gaza, Karni and Rafah, have both been closed since June. These unprecedented closures have devastated the Gazan economy, especially the private sector. Prices are now spiralling. In the last couple of weeks a sack of flour has gone from 80 Shekels to 200 Shekels. Other essentials, like a batch of hearing aids for 300 deaf children at the Atfaluna School in Gaza, are now being held by the Israeli military on "security" grounds. The closures have also left thousands of civilians stranded both in and outside of Gaza. The UN Office for Humanitarian Affairs has calculated that at least 100,000 Palestinians have been denied passage either into or out of Gaza since Karni and Rafah were shut. Gaza journalist Saleh-Al-Naami recently revealed that Gazans who desperately need urgent, sometimes lifesaving medical treatment, are being denied passage out of the Strip unless they agree to become Shin Bet informants. Al-Naami claims retired Shin Bet officers admitted they had instructions to practice the harshest degree of coercion in order to force Palestinian patients to become Israeli informants. His allegations have been backed by the Israeli Physicians for Human Rights. Israel’s intention to cut fuel and power supplies to Gaza are a total violation of international law. So is collective punishment, yet this is blatantly Israel’s strategy in Gaza. But the EU, plus the rest of Europe and the United States, have systematically ignored Israel’s manufactured humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Benita Ferrero-Waldner is obviously not to blame for what Israel is doing, and neither is the EU. Israel alone is responsible for its actions in Gaza. But if the EU is serious about ending the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, rather than carefully worded statements that downplay the reality on the ground, it must use its leverage to impose an economic embargo on Israel to end the blockade.