To: jackjc who wrote (103205 ) 1/14/2008 1:06:25 PM From: E. Charters Respond to of 313059 Taditionally with more socialsimo governments BC has turned up its nose at resource projects that would employ scads of people. The Big Ledge, a zinc project of some 30 million tons that would employ 6000 people in the construction phase and 2500 thereafter, was refused by the prevailing Socreds (emphasis on the red part) back in the 70's, becauze Cominco wanted a tax guarantee that they would make 16% rate of return on their investment (800 million). That was way too much new money for the Socreds. I can't figure it out. It is tax money, particularly the workers income tax they would not see otherwise. Who cares about the corporate tax? What about the VATs, manufacturing taxes, land tax, and income? The Wigwam, the Big Ledge and about 4 or 5 others in the Revelstroke to Slocan trough, constituting about 100+ million tons of fairly medium grade zinc (3 to 6% open pit Zn plus silver, some Pb) never got exploited and may never. I see the odd company is poking around the area today, but no news. And we have the Stikine to St. Elias range copper corridor. Cominco people used to fly the area in the 70's pointing some pretty special laser illuminated XRF equipment out the door of a helicopter. Even on a fly-by, the Gossans of those valleys would register copper, so they could get a preliminary idea which ones to land on and sample. Based on eyeballing the gossans a Veep of TeckCOM told me that there were probably 20 or more copper mines from Northern BC into Alaska. But their isolation and the prevailing copper price militated against their development at the time. Cominco had its ace in the hole of flow-thru water power near the Trail smelter that made the economics sweet for their metal production in southern BC. But the NDP kept taking them back to the table dangling itty bitty tax deductions in return for taking over their hydro. They even got some Cominco execs to admit that their costs to maintain that hydro was as much as they would pay for BC power. That is if BC hydro did not jack your contract based on inductive load surges and contract fees. They do that. Your own gen sets won't do that for some strange reason. The reality is a power contract costs you double what the retail rates are if you have big motors. BC power rates on the face of it, assuming they have the power, are the lowest in Canada because they are based on flow water. So it looks good on paper at first. The buy-out of Trail's power forced Cominco into declining economics. And we have the Windy Craggy story. Up the Stikine area. They find the world's larges VMS type copper deposit. 400 million tons of 1.4% copper. And that as I pointed out is not all their is up there. The NDP are in power at the time. Geddes is not exactly the most scientific organization and the best of lobbyists. But they presented a pretty credible case to the government about waste, run off and closure. NDP had the ear muffs on. The stories they circulated was that it was all a scam. The people on the street were the beneficiaries of all these village whisperers telling them there was no copper there. The grade was too low, and even if it were mined, the fish would all die. Now that was in an area where the salmon were uniquely adapted to high copper levels in the water. +20 PPM did not phase them. There is loads of natural run off the fish had been acclimatised to for millenia. All the company's research told them that they could get the levels down lower than that. A leading US environmental expert testified that they company could easily do better with prevailing technology and criticized both the government's position and Geddes' work-up, saying it need not be taken that the project had much of an environmental impact when handled correctly. NDP screwed the ear muffs tighter and grimaced. More negative publicity ensued. They closed the door on development. Then the arguments ensued about how much compensation Geddes should received. The company lobbied for years on getting opportunity costs. They got about what they had spent and that was that. The company nosed dived, the shareholders lost much of their stock value. Losses to shareholders was in the 100's of millions. So the NDP turned the area into a park for good measure and turned it over to an Indian band to run it. I would say the fuzzy mindedness of the BC government no matter the political stripe runs deep and scary. The latest refusal on Kemess North, based on its supposed environmental foot print, when they are mining the exact same stuff about 1 km south, makes me a bit leery too. BC is scared of mines. Once they were the life blood of the province. Wood is not working out too well now withe high energy costs and increasing difficulty of access to good timber. What are BC-ites going to do? Just about all the manufacturing industry of BC associated with mining and manufacturing of mining and milling equipment left the province about 20 years ago. You used to be able to just about build a mine from an office swivel chair by phoning around suppliers in the lower mainland. Ditto Toronto. Now you would be hard pressed to find someone who sells pipe wrenches or mine muckers. (the boots, not the scoop tram.). EC<:-}