To: Valuepro who wrote (60850 ) 8/23/2008 6:15:13 PM From: Proud Deplorable Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 78419 It's hard to know exactly, I admit. I have spoken with him numerous times and a few times in public. I speak my mind as people know and don't pull punches. I told him I think that his mixing religion with gold and silver is damaging his credibility and that people with scriptural knowledge can punch holes in his analogies quite easily. Now here is where we must work with what we have. He does a lot of research...a LOT and is solidly on the side of those who see silver as a monetary instrument not only as a commodity. His reports of retail silver being nonexistent are absolutely true. If he is assisting people in coming to silver then he is a friend of mine in that sense and so rather than eat own own children I'd rather support him and not make judgments on his religion which I happen to disagree with 100% Does he front run stocks? I don't know as I'm not a subscriber and am not interested in gold or silver stocks anymore since this ARU rip off offer from the Kinrats, but I suspect he does but have no evidence. I just take what he has to say generally, with great interest, but do not take his tips, in fact I'm finished taking tips from ANY newsletter writers period as I see this whole industry as evil and crooked although not from a religious standpoint. A mine is a hole in the ground with a liar on top. Unfortunately the miners these days hire, in many ways, the spinners in the form of news letter writers. If one questions this they can always go to once popular sites like 321 and read the nonsense (in my opinion) and stock hype often posted there posing as opinions on the current goings on in the industry and the world, with stock suggestions thrown in at the end of some articles that, in my opinion, again might have been interesting until I started reading the 'hook'. Any of us here think we know more than he, Butler, Gata or others should write their own articles because Butler and the good people at GATA are not paid shills. I prefer to listen to these guys. I don't listen to Morgan as I see him as wishy washy and he makes me feel quite uncomfortable. There is interesting objective commentary on silver trading here in case you don't know about it:silveraxis.com http://silveraxis.com/todayinsilver/