To: Peter Dierks who wrote (25844 ) 11/23/2009 4:07:46 AM From: Maurice Winn 2 Recommendations Respond to of 36921 Here they are: www-pcmdi.llnl.gov Tel. (925) 422-3840 Fax (925) 422-7675 Acting Program Director, Karl Taylor Administrative Assistant, Christine McCallister Name Position E-mail Phone Number Taylor, Karl Acting Program Director taylor13@llnl.gov (925) 423-3623 Bonfils, Celine Research Scientist bonfils2@llnl.gov (925) 423-9923 Boyle, Jim Research Scientist boyle5@llnl.gov (925) 422-1824 Caldwell, Peter Research Scientist caldwell19@llnl.gov (925) 422-4197 Covey, Curt Research Scientist covey1@llnl.gov (925) 422-1828 Doutriaux, Charles Computer Scientist doutriaux1@llnl.gov (925) 422-1487 Drach, Bob Computer Scientist drach1@llnl.gov (925) 422-8303 Gleckler, Peter Research Scientist gleckler1@llnl.gov (925) 422-7631 Hoang, Tony Systems Administrator thoang@llnl.gov (925) 423-6733 Ivanova, Detelina Postdoctoral Researcher ivanova2@llnl.gov (925) 422-5790 Klein, Stephen Research Scientist klein21@llnl.gov (925) 423-9777 McCallister, Christine Administrative Assistant mccalister4@llnl.gov (925) 422-3840 McClean, Julie Research Scientist mcclean3@llnl.gov (925) 422-3132 McCoy, Renata Computer Scientist mccoy20@llnl.gov (925) 424-5237 Phillips, Tom Research Scientist phillips14@llnl.gov (925) 422-0072 Potter, Jerry Research Scientist (retired) gpotter@llnl.gov (925) 422-1832 (925) 784-8163 (c) Santer, Ben Research Scientist santer1@llnl.gov (925) 422-3840 Sperber, Ken Research Scientist sperber1@llnl.gov (925) 422-7720 Williams, Dean Computer Scientist williams13@llnl.gov (925) 423-0145 Xie, Shaocheng Research Scientist xie2@llnl.gov (925) 422-6023 Zhang, Yuying Research Scientist zhang24@llnl.gov (925) 423-8505 Zhang, Yunyan Research Scientist zhang25@llnl.gov (925) 422-5778 UCRL-MI-119847 > from Maurice Winn to santer1@llnl.gov cc taylor13@llnl.gov date Mon, Nov 23, 2009 at 10:05 PM subject Somebody is making claims about you. mailed-by gmail.com hide details 10:05 PM (0 minutes ago) <<In one email, Benjamin Santer from the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in Livermore, Calif., wrote to the director of the climate-study center that he was "tempted to beat" up Mr. Michaels. Mr. Santer couldn't be reached for comment Sunday.>> Is that true? [I don't mean that you couldn't be reached - I mean the interest in beating up Pat Michaels]. <<"This is horrible," said Pat Michaels, a climate scientist at the Cato Institute in Washington who is mentioned negatively in the emails. "This is what everyone feared. Over the years, it has become increasingly difficult for anyone who does not view global warming as an end-of-the-world issue to publish papers. This isn't questionable practice, this is unethical." >> Maurice Winn Auckland New Zealand