To: arun gera who wrote (233805 ) 12/21/2009 12:02:10 AM From: Skeeter Bug Respond to of 306849 arun, citi did a secondary to raise money BEFORE the government sold its shares. again - citi got to raise and keep more money and the tax payers suffered a big fat loss... big money center bank gets billions... tax payers lose billions... again... geithner isn't stupid... he works for the banks! ps - citi was given a #38 billion tax credit, too. citi: +$38 billion tax payers: -$38 billion all brought to you by our corporate sponsored politicians and their appointees! ----------------------------- Earlier this week, when Citi announced its plan to repay TARP, we characterized it as a mixed blessing and noted that we were disappointed that the plan began with capital raising to repay the TARP preferreds and ended with the sale of government shares rather than the other way around. In retrospect, we had no idea of our gift for understatement. We believe that there would have been plenty of demand for government shares at over $4 per share because it would been a clear step toward a normal ownership structure. Instead, by forcing the sale of common while still having the overhang of the government, their shareholders, most prominently including the American taxpayer, have been needlessly diluted. Citigroup announced Wednesday evening that its offering to repay TARP was priced at $3.15 per share, 20% below last Friday's close. As a result, the government did not sell any of its shares, obviously not wanting to show a loss versus its $3.25 cost basis. Bullet As a result, the taxpayers' 7.7 billion share stake in Citi has been diluted from about 33% of the company to about 26% without a single dollar being raised for Treasury. Value has been permanently lost because the dilution is permanent. Bullet We estimate that between August and November, some 37.9 billion shares of C traded hands at or above $4/share. There was ample opportunity to sell most if not all of the UST common at a gain, which is the most troubling aspect of Citi's relationship with the government for private sector providers of capital. Bullet Instead, Citi's private shareholders continue to live with a large government stake. As long as that stake persists, we believe there will be a cloud over Citi stock as shareholders will fear that the company will be run more on Washington logic than on business logic. Bullet We believe Citi will end up with about 30B shares and a tangible book value of just under $4 per share. We believe that the stock can trade back toward tangible book, but we do not see it earning a premium until the government stake has been sold. He is giving Gordon Brown who sold billions of UK gold at $275 a run for the title of finance moron.