To: Jan A. Van Hummel who wrote (7593 ) 11/8/1997 10:28:00 AM From: Mark Zavist Respond to of 14577
S3 finds error in how revenue was recorded -- Incorrect methods were used for several quarters in totaling sales in the int'l distribution channel By Andrew MacLellan Silicon Valley- Graphics-chip maker S3 Inc. has taken an unexpected loss in its third quarter after an error in the manner in which sales were recorded in the international distribution channel forced the company to revise revenue for several prior quarters. The revenue restatement is $40 million to $70 million less than previously reported, and is expected to result in a cumulative decrease of 14 cents to 29 cents per share, the company said. Following an internal audit, S3, which spent much of this year without a chief financial officer, will disclose the full extent of the accounting error as part of its latest quarterly filing with the SEC. Until the audit is completed, the financial community is largely withholding judgment. Hambrecht & Quist Inc., San Francisco, is maintaining a hold recommendation on the company. S3 stocks took a hit on Wall Street, however, closing down on Nov. 4 by more than a point at 7-11/32, as the accounting slip-up compounded investor doubts about future product plans, according to Charles F. Boucher, an analyst at UBS Securities Equity Research, San Francisco. "The stock was down because there may have been a core group of investors for whom this accounting fiasco was the straw that broke the camel's back," Boucher said. "It's an embarrassment to have to restate. I don't think this will affect any earnings or revenue projections going forward, but it tarnishes the company's image." S3 attributes the problem to revenue recorded for products held by its international distributors but which had not yet been resold to the end customer, a deviation from standard accounting policies, said S3 president and chief executive Gary Johnson. S3 expects that those 2-D and 3-D chips incorrectly recognized as generating revenue will clear the distribution channel and reach OEMs during this quarter. "We are currently implementing measures to ensure that this type of error will not recur," Johnson said in a prepared statement. "Any new shipments into the channel during, and subsequent to, the fourth quarter of 1997 will be recognized during the quarter in which those products move off the distributors' shelves in line with company policy," he said. S3 last month reported third-quarter revenue of $120.4 million, up 0.76% from the year-ago quarter, while net income fell 66%, to $3.9 million. Earnings for the nine months ended Sept. 30 were $22.1 million, down from $32.9 million for the same period in 1996. The company's leadership position in the graphics-accelerator market is under siege by dozens of competitors that have reduced the healthy margins S3 realized in 1996. The revenue oversight is under review by independent auditors, S3 management, and the company's own audit committee, which consists entirely of outside directors, according to Walt Amaral, S3's chief financial officer and senior vice president of finance, who was named to the post in August. "We have initiated tighter monitoring and control procedures to ensure strict compliance with our revenue recognition policy moving forward," Amaral said. Copyright (c) 1997 CMP Media Inc. [New Search] [Search the Web] You can reach this article directly:techweb.com