To: Sector Investor who wrote (528 ) 11/12/1997 1:37:00 PM From: Sector Investor Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1629
Synopsis of a Research report from Everen issued today Everen states that despite recent declines in Ascend Communications' share price, they continue to rate the common stock an Intermediate Term Market Underperformer with a target Price of $25-$30 and a Long Term Market Performer with a target Price: $33-$37. Based on several internal and external factors, they believe ASND's fundamentals continue to be unstable and they would advise avoiding the stock and using increases in share price as an opportunity to reduce positions. They state that based on the company's third quarter results, recent visit with management, and general industry conditions they continue to see the following issues as a concern over the next couple of quarters: TNT issues: ASND continues to make enhancements to the Max TNT remote access product. While some feature software releases are expected in Q4, the company has just released the TNT in Europe, and will not release it in Japan until Q1 FY98. Remote access revenue accounts for 50% of the total [this was unclear]. Increasing competition: They think that for the first time, CSCO, BAY, COMS, and even SHVA have developed competitive solutions. Furthermore, these new entrants have entered the market at lower prices, placing pressure on revenue growth and margins. These products are just beginning to ship so ASND's ability to maintain its leadership has yet to be seen. ************************************************************** Sector's comment. It's more than prices that are important here, it's the total package - density, product features and interfaces, software service and support and strategic business relationships that win and keep customers. Everen and most other analysts are completely missing this. ASND clearly has the "best of breed" total package, especially at the carrier level, where the growth and large contracts are and is continuing to build strong strategic relationships. *************************************************************** Regarding international growth, Everen states that given the economic unrest in Japan, most companies have lowered their expectation for growth there. Japan currently accounts for approximately 13% of ASND's total revenue. They think that the effects of this downturn could be especially pronounced in Q1 FY98, where Japan's fiscal year-end during this period generally provides a boost to a seasonally soft domestic quarter. They state that furthermore, while some companies are experiencing an uptick in European revenue contribution, it is still, unfortunately, a sluggish market for ASND. Regarding their view of a maturing frame relay market Outlook for the frame relay market growth has declined from 30% growth to a range of 10% to 15% based on price pressure and market saturation. This has had an impact on ASND where frame relay revenue accounts for an estimated 27% of its total revenue. During the third quarter, ASND actually experienced an 8% sequential decline. Furthermore, the company has indicated that it expects price declines of 20% to 30% next year. Everen is projecting this segment to only grow 10% in fiscal 1998. ************************************************************** Sector's comment. I don't see it this way. ASND has taken F/R to OC-12 and (coming) OC-48 speeds - a far cry from the previous 45MB. This is essentially a new market for F/R, especially with the telcos. I think ASND's F/R will do very well here. *************************************************************** Everen's view of management changes, (mainly Ashby and Misunas). They believe that while these moves increase the depth of ASND's management and is a plus, their contributions have yet to be seen. Everen's view of ASND investor confidence. They state that they think one of the worst missteps that ASND has taken was its continued reassurance of product acceptance and earnings outlook, and its ability to react to the numerous and material market changes. From the time of the merger with CSCC, up and until its Q3 pre-release, Everen believes that ASND was overly optimistic relative to the serious challenges it was facing. They feel that ASND's inability to live up to these expectations set by management, hurt their credibility. This clearly places the company in a position to have to prove itself via financial results before the financial community is willing to believe that all of the internal issues and external issues have been successfully addressed. ************************************************************** Sector's comment. I think this is the problem in a nutshell - perception by the investment community. They will require PROOF - in terms of earnings, meetings and new contracts before this stock will move significantly upward. This is a great buying opportunity for us on SI as we can the detailed factors leading to this proof (new products, alliances, etc) on a daily basis. I think we can see this "proof" coming (in Spades, IMO). *************************************************************** Overall, they continue to rate the stock the same based on their perception of an increasing competitive landscape, no resolution yet of internal issues, and lack of confidence in ASND's ability to deliver increasing sequential results. They state that while they have forecasted sequential improvements through the balance of fiscal 1998, they believe Q1 1998 could be at risk to the extent the Japanese economy does not improve. They have adjusted their Q1 FY98 earnings to reflect this potential risk. They would continue to avoid the stock until such time that the company can demonstrate sustained earnings improvements, a stable operating model in the face of increasing competition, and the ability to maintain its leadership position. ************************************************************** Sector's comment. By the time ASND has "proved" this and these analysts come out with their upgrades, ASND stock will no longer be in the $20s or even $30s. *************************************************************** Everen's comments on valuation: Based on the percentage gain Everen's previous targets now represent and the added uncertainty in Q1 FY98, they have adjusted their intermediate term target price downwards to $25 and their Long-term target to $33. They state that this represents a relative multiple to the S&P 500 Index of 1.08 times their 1998 earnings estimates and 1.22 times their 1999 estimates. They believe the ASND's near-term uncertainty warrants a multiple close to that of the S&P 500 Index, with earnings projected to grow only 11% in FY98. Based on ASND's ability to increase its earnings growth to 20% in 1999, they believe its multiple can expand slightly. ************************************************************** Sector's comment. How generous of them. I feel that looking back a year from now, we will label this period as one of the all time great buying opportunities for ASND since the IPO. How many of us will take advantage of it? ***************************************************************