To: Threshold who wrote (6822 ) 4/24/2011 11:42:53 PM From: marcos 1 Recommendation Respond to of 16592 Another great post T, good stuff ... one possibility i was wondering about, was if the whole field including control plot had K sufficient for a carrot crop in the first place, especially with carrots not being particularly woody [isn't it the woody bits as in stalks bark skins etc that most need K?.. plus for overall vigour, yes], then the whole thing being quite inconclusive makes sense ... you'd think they'd test the soil and make sure to find some K-deficient in the first place, but we don't know this Sekita, and it looks like they're not parting with any of the fine detail in re the test, they don't even say if carrot quantity and quality met normal expectations for a crop, or what Embrapa the federal ag dept is famous for doing a lot of fine research, be nice to see them test thermofert ... thorough job is in order, test everything before during and after crop Lots of opinion on the thread last few days, i agree with much of it, two or three things i disagree with strongly ... there, sure told those folks off, serve em right Yes the release was poorly written, might be only poor translation but looks like poorly thought as well This doesn't excuse a stupid market reaction though ... that was wild panic dumping, people got spooked, means they didn't understand the concept in the first place ... the great advantage of thermofert is in its endurance, there's no way to test this on one crop of carrots, you'd have to plant three or four minimum in quick rotation for a test, other crops likely to be more useful for the purpose ... i don't see how it can fail to work, fritted ferts and amendments been used elsewhere for decades, of course they have to get particle size and degree of glassification right, maybe they didn't this time, release pretty much says so, well that's an easy thing to fix imho Anyway i didn't sell any even after it started bouncing, and don't intend to ... might add a few on any more dumpolas, though that's hard as it's already largest position and outsize ... likely do some head-shaking at my fellow man, more than normal maybe even