To: DiViT who wrote (25319 ) 11/16/1997 10:18:00 AM From: John Rieman Respond to of 50808
Macrovision 7.0 is the next target to defeat........................ Subject: Re: Possible method to defeat Macrovision 7.0 From: "Curt David" <CDavid@noporkproducts4me.SRSales.com> Date: 1997/10/21 Message-ID: <62id0k$dmg@newsops.execpc.com> Newsgroups: alt.video.dvd,sci.engr.television.advanced,sci.electronics.misc [More Headers] I don't really disagree with you in principal. I'd be tempted to do the same thing. But, how old are your kids? My four year old does a good job handling CD-ROMS. My 2 year old probably wouldn't be so good though. The trouble with sticking with VHS only is that these tapes degrade and lose quality rather quickly. With Disney titles you never know when it will finally break and if you can replace it. I guess you could make the same case with DVD, but if your kids are 4 and older, then you should be able to teach them to handle the discs carefully. Rick Richardson wrote in article <344C3F51.673B4539@dgii.com>... >I've been contemplating getting a DVD player for XMAS this year. >However, the insertion of Macrovision 7.0 is a big problem. I have >two children that are too young to handle CD type media. If I >buy a DVD, I expect to be able to dub, say, Disney DVD's to a VCR >tape so that the kids can safely play them on the VCRs in their >rooms. There is absolutely nothing illegal or immoral about >what I want to do here. > >It sounds like Macrovision 7 would make this impossible. I can't >afford to buy every movie in both VHS and DVD. > >I've never opened a DVD player, but I checked out a couple of >digital video encoder chips made by Philips and Motorola. These >chips contain the Macrovision 7.0 insertion circuitry. Philips >makes the SAA7120 (with Macrovision) and the SAA7121 (without >Macrovision). Motorola makes the MC44724 (with MV) and the >MC44725 (without MV). Each set of chips is pinout compatible >with its non-Macrovision sibling. > >It seems to me that if you had one of these encoders in a DVD >player, you could buy the non-MV version of the chip from your >local chip distributor and solder it in place of the chip that >is in the DVD. Voila, no Macrovision. > >First questions: Does this sound like a reasonable plan? Would >it work? Anybody tried it? > >Second question: Can we put together a list of digital video >to NTSC/RGB encoder chips that are found in DVD players? I'm >particularly interested in the endoder chip used in the Sony >DVP-S3000 and whether it has a non-MV sibling. I would >definitely be interested in buying any DVD player for which >the endoder chip has pin-compatible non-Macrovision sibling. > >Failing a way to disable the Macrovision 7.0, I can't see >this family buying a DVD player for a few more years until >the kids get older and can handle fragile disks. > >-- >Rick Richardson Sr. Principal Engr. >Digi Intl. Email: rick@dgii.com >11001 Bren Rd. East dgii.com >Minnetonka, MN 55343 Tel: (612) 912-3212