As Regulators Pressed Changes, Corzine Pushed Back, and Won  By AZAM AHMED and BEN PROTESS | New York Times – 2 hours 52 minutes ago
Share 0 Email Print
Months before MF Global teetered on the brink, federal regulators were seeking to rein in the types of risky trades that contributed to the firm's collapse. But they faced opposition from an influential opponent: Jon S. Corzine, the head of the then little-known brokerage firm.
As a former United States senator and a former governor of New Jersey, as well as the leader of Goldman Sachs in the 1990s, Mr. Corzine carried significant weight in the worlds of Washington and Wall Street. While other financial firms employed teams of lobbyists to fight the new regulation, MF Global's chief executive in meetings over the last year personally pressed regulators to halt their plans.
The agency proposing the rule, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, relented. Wall Street, which has been working to curb many financial regulations, won another battle.
Yet with MF Global in bankruptcy and regulators scrambling to find $630 million in missing customer funds, Mr. Corzine's effort may come back to haunt him.
The proposed rule would have restricted a complicated transaction that allowed MF Global in essence to borrow money from its own customers. Brokerage firms are allowed to use customers' money to earn interest, not unlike banks, but this rule would have outlawed using customer funds for a loan to the firm itself.
While such financing is not unknown on Wall Street, it carries substantial risk. An outside lender would require a firm like MF Global to produce strict accounting for a loan. Without that oversight, regulators worried that firms could use such internal customer money inappropriately, including bolstering the business in hard times. The proposed rule would have affected several dozen other financial firms.
Regulators are now examining whether these transactions explain the missing money at MF Global, according to people briefed on the investigation.
The C.F.T.C. has issued subpoenas to MF Global's auditor, PricewaterhouseCoopers, and the Securities and Exchange Commission is also conducting an inquiry. The Federal Bureau of Investigation is also looking into the missing money, although there is no indication that criminal laws were broken.
Still, Mr. Corzine has hired a prominent criminal defense lawyer, Andrew J. Levander, a partner at Dechert, according to people briefed on the matter.
Mr. Levander represented a number of Wall Street executives after the financial crisis of 2008, including the independent directors of Lehman Brothers and John A. Thain, the former chief executive of Merrill Lynch.
Neither Mr. Corzine nor MF Global has been accused of wrongdoing. MF Global declined to comment and Mr. Corzine did not respond to a request for comment.
Just three months ago, Mr. Corzine's firm assured regulators that the proposed rule could cripple the futures brokerage industry by hurting their profitability. In a letter, MF Global told regulators that they were trying to "fix something that is not broken," adding that the firm was not aware of any brokerage firm like itself that was unable to "provide to their customers upon request any segregated funds."
MF Global's clients, including hedge funds, individual investors and agricultural firms, now know a different reality, as the clients struggle to locate their missing funds. And regulators are pushing to again move forward on the rule. But for MF Global, the rule will come too late.
The trades at the center of MF Global's downfall - big bets on the debt of five European countries - may yet prove profitable. But they raise questions about why the firm escalated its risk-taking under Mr. Corzine, leading to a crisis of confidence among rating agencies, creditors and regulators.
As a former sovereign debt trader at Goldman Sachs, Mr. Corzine wagered that the European regulators would backstop any default. So even as dark clouds circled over Europe, he sensed an opportunity. Starting in late 2010, MF Global began to accumulate short-term sovereign debt of countries like Italy, Spain and Portugal.
MF Global financed these purchases through complex transactions known as repurchase agreements. In these, the bonds themselves were used as collateral for a loan to purchase them. The interest paid on that loan was less than the interest the bonds paid out, earning the firm a profit from the spread.
While that practice is quite common, the C.F.T.C. wanted to crack down on such lending in those instances when customer funds were used. The C.F.T.C. proposal would have also banned the use of client funds to buy foreign sovereign debt.
It is unclear whether the firm used client funds to purchase the risky bonds of Italy, Spain, and other debt-laden European nations, but experts say it is not unusual for such transactions to be paid for with customer money.
A person close to MF Global said the firm did not use client funds to finance these trades.
Leading the government's effort to curtail these arcane practices was Gary Gensler, the chairman of C.F.T.C., who had worked for Mr. Corzine at Goldman Sachs. Mr. Gensler pushed for the proposed change in October 2010, and planned to bring it to a vote this summer.
MF Global has four outside lobbyists in Washington, tiny by Wall Street standards. But it was Mr. Corzine who marshaled the firm's response to the proposal, lobbying most of the agency's five commissioners directly. One commissioner said he visited with Mr. Corzine in MF Global's headquarters, and acknowledged being impressed by the Wall Street titan, said a person with direct knowledge of the meeting who asked for anonymity because the meeting was private.
The C.F.T.C. polices the markets for futures trades. Staff members there often do not have a Wall Street pedigree.
Mr. Corzine's background in finance made him highly credible, agency officials said.
Mr. Corzine's efforts culminated on July 20, as the agency was preparing for a vote on the proposal. That day, MF Global executives were on four different calls with the agency's staff. Mr. Corzine himself was on two of those calls.
One of the calls was with Mr. Gensler. Both men are active Democrats, and served on financial panels together recently.
Shortly after the calls, Mr. Gensler, aware that he could not push the vote through, decided to delay the proposal indefinitely.
But after MF Global's blowup and the ensuing fallout from the missing funds, regulators said they were considering pushing again on the rule.
"I think it's time to move ahead - expeditiously - and make that rule tighter, cleaner, and ultimately safer, for customers," Bart Chilton, a Democratic member of the C.F.T.C., said in a statement.
Mr. Chilton also wants the agency to require firms to produce detailed documentation "to ensure that the funds are really there."
Internal repurchase agreements emerged on Wall Street in 2005. At the time, the transactions were off limits to banks and brokerage firms. But at the urging of Lehman Brothers, the C.F.T.C. blessed the new approach to getting financing.
In September 2008, Lehman collapsed amid a global financial crisis. It later was disclosed that Lehman's use of another little-known repurchase agreement allowed it to temporarily obscure billions of dollars in losses.
Michael J. de la Merced, Andrew Ross Sorkin and Peter Lattman contributed reporting.
More From NY Times
@yahoofinance on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook
Explore Related Contents
Public workers, retirees oppose RI pension re … Commissioning of IOCL's Paradip Refinery Pushed … Fla. businesses to pay out more for unemploym … Jon Corzine Resigns From MF Global Posts, Won’t … Summary Box: EU launches satellite navigation Fitch: Hovnanian's rating at 'restricted defa … Corzine and regulator worked together at Gold …
Golman Sachs protest results in 17 arrests
U.S. Economic Data Shows Tepid Growth, Hatzius Says
Goldman Sachs protest results in 17 arrests
More From 
Report Shows Gain in Jobs but Growth Still Sluggish The Caucus: Early Jobs Projections Could Haunt Obama in 2012 Wall Street Set to End the Week Down
All Comments Shared On Facebook
Leave a comment... Comment Guidelines
Please Enter a Comment
Post As
78 comments
Popular Now Newest Oldest Most Replied
33users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
biomedlives 2 hours ago "Mr. Corzine's background in finance made him highly credible, agency officials said." It was reasonable to say the same of Bernard Madoff, up until the time his Ponzi scheme blew up. 1 Reply
16users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Verne 2 hours ago Very sad ending for the people who invested in MF Global. This is why I trust no-one to manage my money but myself. Once you get the hang of it...its fun! 1 Reply
14users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Arthur about an hour ago There was a time when Americans would'nt take this #$%$ and actually did something about it.Our forefathers would have been shooting by now. 1 Reply
12users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
AlexG about an hour ago As usual, the problem is not lack of regulations but lack of smart regulators.......problem could also be regulators who are under influence or who are corrupt. Reply
18users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!2users disliked this comment
Independent_Thinker 2 hours ago Wait. You're telling me that a Big-Corporation fatcat, who ended up destroying a company (and AMERICAN LIVELIHOODS) was fighting for LESS OVERSIGHT AND REGULATION??
Why, I'm shocked!! Just shocked, I tells ya.. (not).
-signed: One of the 99% 3 Replies
13users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!1users disliked this comment
Ken 2 hours ago And there you have it...It is clowns like Mr Corzine that are corrupting the entire world financial system forcing cournties to bail out other countries. Forcing the USA to bail out all banking. This is something that must STOP!!! These bansters are robbing the middle class blind and no one is... More 1 Reply
5users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
something that might work ... 40 minutes ago Hey NY Times- he is a D-E-M-O-C-R-A-T ex Senator/Governor 1 Reply
20users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!3users disliked this comment
ward p 2 hours ago Notice that this slimeball is a Democrat. Notice that the Enron deal was made up of Republicans. Guess what? Both parties are totally corrupt. Time for a new party of common sense. Start with term limits, no golden parachute political benefits. (unlimited lifetime healthcare, full salary pensions... More 3 Replies
3users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Arch Stanton 59 minutes ago You think the OWS crowd will march on his house? He's a Dem; what do you think? 2 Replies
1users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
don'ttreadonme about an hour ago Remind me again which party primarily composes the persons taking part in 'occupy wall street' and then which party Corzine is from.
Just proof if the 'occupy wall street' crowd is true to their stance they would have to turn their back on their party. 4 Replies
3users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
HowardH about an hour ago One set of laws, one set of rules, everybody complies, otherwise it's the good-old-boy network at it's worst. OJ Simpson proved it: If you have enough money, you can get away with murder. 1 Reply
5users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Log In Eye about an hour ago John Corzine for Precedent!
Let him be the first or many fat cat crooks we march off to prison. Reply
7users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!1users disliked this comment
Mike about an hour ago It interesting to Note that it was Democrats such as Corzine, Robert Rubins, that mastermined so many schemes which defrauded investors. These are friends of the Democrat Bill Clinton who forced no down loans upon banks without voter approval or any vetting.
... More 4 Replies
3users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
pete 45 minutes ago Corzine should have the jail cell next to Madoff. Maybe they can shower together. 1 Reply
2users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
dfgdf about an hour ago We need to divorce wall st from Washington NOW. 2 Replies
5users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Consider This 2 hours ago If businesses / corporations at all times acted in ethical and responsible manner then regulation would not be required. The American legal system for all it's strength specifies what the limits are, what must not be done. If it is not explicitly stated as no, then it is legal. Laws in most... More 1 Reply
2users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
American Patriot 43 minutes ago Corzine's a Liberal Democrat, he doesn't have to follow the same rules as the rest of us. Learn to live with it. 1 Reply
2users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
smitty 57 minutes ago Gee another liberal democrat hypocrit. This is the same man who blamed everything on the repubs. Go figure. Another fraud perpetrated upon ignorant yankee democrat voters who vote for a handout. Our country not not continue to do this or we will be finished. It may already be too late. 4 more years... More 1 Reply
3users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
Strangelove about an hour ago Another example of influence winning over enforcement when it comes to regulating Wall Street. Wall Street and Washington share the same bed and mistress. Reply
2users liked this comment Please sign in to rate! Please sign in to rate!0users disliked this comment
swampfox 38 minutes ago Can't believe the greed and corruption of these Republican Wall Street CEO's. May they rot in hell. Oh, wait a minute, Corzine is a liberal Democrap who raised money for no hope and all I have left is change guy Barack Obama.. May these lying, corrupt, hypocritical liberal Democraps rot in hell or... More Reply
More
Post a comment
Loading...
Sponsored Links ( What's this? )
2011 New Car Prices Buying a New Vehicle? Find Discount Pricing in Your Zip Code!
www.WhyPaySticker.com 850% Penny Stock Gains Our last pick jumped 850% - Join our 100% Free Newsletter Today
www.PennyStocksExpert.com Free Penny Stock Alerts Join our 100% Free Newsletter & get our next big winner!
www.PennyStockGains.com Free Penny Stock Alerts Join our free newsletter and get penny stock picks that jump high.
PennyStockAdvice.com
Top Stories »
Wall St falls before confidence vote in GreeceReuters Stocks retreated on Friday as political instability in Europe overshadowed encouraging domestic jobs data and investors …
Euro zone finds no new money for debt crisis at G20Reuters
Groupon shares surge but concerns lingerReuters
Jobs report hints at some improvementReuters
MF Global CEO Jon Corzine quits under fireReuters
AdChoices 
QUOTES
Recent Quotes Portfolios
Recent Quotes Symbol Price Change % Chg INTC 23.731 -0.47 -1.94% ARMH 31.20 +1.74 +5.91% AMD 5.66 -0.07 -1.22% PFE 19.61 -0.27 -1.36% DWA 17.44 -0.13 -0.74% MFGLQ.PK 0.258 -0.02 -7.19% AMTD 16.86 -0.20 -1.17%
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
Enter Symbol
Save List to Portfolio »
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.
Featured Content
Recent Facebook Activity
|
