To: Richnorth who wrote (150 ) 11/22/1997 6:34:00 PM From: Mark Adams Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 1756
Any comments on the article found in this weeks Economist ateconomist.com I'm long gold mining stocks, but if the Central Banks consider this position valid, troubling times could lie ahead.... <snip>Yellow peril A provocative study* published this summer by America's Federal Reserve also deserves attention. It concluded that the world would be better off if central banks sold their gold, and it offers a novel explanation why. Keeping gold reserves off the market, argue the authors, means that resources are wasted. Extracting new gold from the ground, at an average cost of close to $300 an ounce, is not necessary. If the demands of gold-using industries, from semiconductor makers to dentists and jewellers, could be met by running down stocks rather than mining, there would be a considerable economic gain. The study estimates that if all countries sold their gold, this would result over time in a net gain in economic welfare of $368 billion. Of this, $342 billion would go to governments, while private-sector users of gold would be $198 billion better off. In the loss column, private owners of gold would be $102 billion worse off due to lower prices, and gold producers would suffer to the tune of $70 billion. The study has the usual disclaimer that it reflects the views of the authors and not those of the Federal Reserve. But the fact that the holder of one quarter of all official gold reserves is asking whether gold could be put to better use cannot be dismissed lightly. The big holders of reserves among emerging economies, such as China and Taiwan, have little gold in their vaults. If the smaller central banks continue to sell gold at a modest rate, then the price may hold steady. But if the big central banks dump the metal then gold could meet the same fate as silver. In the 1870s both Germany and America stopped the regular minting of silver coins. Germany in particular began dumping silver on the market, and by the early 1900s the price had tumbled by two-thirds. For gold bugs, central banks' diminished affection for the yellow metal may not have a silver lining. * "Can Government Gold be Put to Better Use?" By Dale Henderson, John Irons, Stephen Salant and Sebastian Thomas. Federal Reserve International Finance Discussion Paper no. 582. June 1997.