To: LWolf who wrote (2441 ) 11/22/1997 8:06:00 PM From: Richard H. Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 4074
Today I went shopping for a new PC with a soft budget of $1500. I traveled to my local Staples which is about 10 minutes from my house. There were quite a few PC shoppers looking at and trying out the machines. Staples had offerings from Packard Bell and Compaq in the sub $1000 category; HP, Toshiba and NEC in the mid range; and IBM at the top end. Compaq had offering in every category. Compaq dominates the shelf space and was getting the most attention from the shoppers. I disregarded the low end products which I think will be outdated quickly. By quick comparisons I judged Compaq to be superior to HP and NEC in terms of price, features and feel. I grabbed several product brochures and wrote down the prices for the models I was interested in before heading home. Next I went to Micron's web site (real cool) and checked MUEI's products against Compaq. I checked out the preconfigured models with the Free Shipping that is now available. I would guess that shipping is rather expensive, say $100 or so. Obviously there would be no shipping charge if I bought a Compaq at Staples. Here's my comparisons organized by price: Model Compaq 4508 Micron MME 166 Processor Intel P200 MMX Intel P166 MMX Memory 24 MB SDRAM 32 MB SDRAM Hard Drive 3.2 GB 3.2 GB Cache 256 K 512 K CD-ROM 16 X 24 X Modem 33.6 K 56 K Graphics Direct 3D 1MB DiamondStealth 4 MB Monitor 15 inch 15 inch Other Iomega Zip Drive Price $1598 $1599 Model Compaq 4528 Micron MME 233 Micron MME 200 Processor Intel P233 MMX Intel P233 MMX Intel P200 MMX Memory 32 MB SDRAM 32 MB SDRAM 32 MB SDRAM Hard Drive 3.2 GB 3.2 GB 3.2 GB Cache 256 KB 512 KB 512 K CD-ROM 24 X 24 X 24 X Modem 33.6 K 56 K 56 K Graphics Direct 3D 1MB DiamondStealth 4 MB DiamondStealth 4 MB Monitor 15 inch 15 inch 15 inch Other Iomega Zip Drive Iomega Zip Drive Price $1898 $1945 $1835 Model Compaq 4824 Micron XKU 233 Processor Intel PII233 MMX Intel PII233 MMX Memory 32 MB SDRAM 32 MB SDRAM Hard Drive 6.5 GB 3.2 MB Cache 512 KB 512 KB CD-ROM 24 X 16 X Modem 56 K 56 K Graphics Arcade 3D 2 MB Diamond Viper 4 MB Monitor 15 inch 15 inch Other Creative Photo Center Price $2198 $2029 I have used a PC for many years, but admit to being a PC novice. Stretching my budget to $1900, I like Micron P233. Seems like you get a lot more for only $47. For a PII233, Micron XKU looks much better than Compaq. Could one of you guys help me here? At the $1599 price point, I favor Compaq because I get a P200, but I like everything else about the Micron offering. Because of my bias I will probably choose a Micron. My budget says MME166, my heart says XKU233. As a shareholder, I see that Micron does not compete in the under $1500 category. Compaq seems better between $1600 and $1899 because of the higher speed processor for the price. Micron wins over $1900. As a shareholder, I wish MUEI had a sub $1500 box in its lineup and better advertising program. Thank you for your help. Regards, Richard