...CONTINUED.... Congress also has previously worked to address micro cap fraud. In 1990, the Subcommittee on Telecommunications and Finance of the House Commerce Committee took up the issue of penny stock fraud, 9 and ultimately Congress enacted the Penny Stock Reform Act of 1990 (,,Penny Stock Act ") as part of the Securities Enforcement Remedies Act ( "Remedies Act "). 10 The Penny Stock Act expanded the Commission's authority over such previously unregulated persons as promoters who associate with broker-dealers to sell penny stocks, and it required the creation of a toll-free hotline investors could call to obtain the disciplinary history of brokers. The Act also placed significant restrictions on so-called "blank check " offerings and required broker-dealers to disclose more information to customers when selling penny stocks. Finally, the Act called for the creation of an automated quotation system for OTC stocks, which the NASD and Commission already had underway with the OTC Bulletin Board. 9 Penny Stock Market Fraud: Hearings on H.R. 4497 Before the Subcommittee on Telecommunications and Finance of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, 101st Cong. 27 (1990) (Statement of Richard C. Breeden, Chairman of the Commission). 10 Securities Enforcement Remedies and Penny Stock Reform Act of 1990, Pub. L. No. 101-429, 104 Stat. 931.
After the enactment of the Penny Stock Act, the Commission adopted new rules to implement the statute. 11 Among the requirements are rules requiring brokers to give customers specific information before the sale about the market for penny stocks and the broker's compensation. After the sale, the broker must provide clients with monthly statements reporting the market value of the client's penny stocks. The goal of these rules is to provide information to investors and provide prospective investors with an opportunity to consider whether to make a purchase without the pressure of boiler room tactics. 11 Penny Stock Rule Release, surpa, at fn. 1.
In 1993, the Commission amended Exchange Act Rule 15c2-1 1. That rule requires a broker-dealer to review financial and other issuer information before publishing a quotation in the issuer's stock in a quotation media such as the OTC Bulletin Board or the Pink Sheets. The rule also requires brokers to have a reasonable basis for believing the information is accurate. Finally, the amended rule requires broker- dealers to obtain a copy of any trading suspension order in the issuer's Stock for the previous twelve months. 12 12 Exchange Act Release No. 29094 (Apr. 17, 1991), 56 Fed. Reg. 19,148 (Apr. 25, 1991).
In 1993, the Commission conducted an extensive examination sweep with the NASD and state regulators to determine whether firms were complying with the Penny Stock Rules. The sweep found widespread adherence to the Penny Stock Rules, along with generally diminished activity in stocks covered by the Penny Stock Rules. 13 13 Joint Regulatory Penny Stock Examination Sweep (June 1994). Only 14 of the 129 broker-dealer examinations disclosed violations serious enough to warrant consideration of enforcement or disciplinary action.
C. How Micro Cap Fraud Has Changed
Although the Penny Stock Act and Rules and the creation of the OTC Bulletin Board have by and large curbed certain abuses in the market for securities priced under $5, we are now finding that promoters and broker-dealers have adjusted their schemes so that the securities fall outside these measures. The simplest way around the Penny Stock Rules, for example, is to offer or sell securities that do not meet the technical definition of "penny stocks ". The Commission today sees more fraud in mostly lower- priced Nasdaq-listed securities and in securities valued at $5 or more.
In addition, the Internet is being used as a new vehicle to perpetrate securities fraud, especially in the micro cap market (including touting in "chat rooms ", bulletin boards and on e- mail). The Commission has already brought enforcement actions involving fraudulent securities offerings, stock manipulations, 14 and investment advisers fraud through Internet newsletters. 15 The fraudulent securities offerings often promise unreal returns and include everything from interests in an eel farm, 16 an ethanol plant, 17 gold and diamond mining enterprises 19 and a coconut chip enterprise, 19 to more sophisticated offerings of sham promissory notes 20 and bonds purportedly issued by a nonexistent offshore company. 21 The Internet can be used for scams because it provides anonymity, broad circulation and the appearance of legitimacy at low cost. Accordingly, the Commission has been developing an effective surveillance strategy for the Internet. 22 However, the Commission is committed to the legitimate use of the Internet by honest market participants. 14 SEC v. Huttoe, Litigation Release No. 15237 (Jan. 31, 1997), 63 SEC Docket 2383 (Mar. 4, 1997). 15 SEC v. Chelekis, Litigation Release No. 15264 (Feb. 2.5, 1997), 63 SEC Docket 2900 (Mar. 25, 1997). 16 SEC v. Odulo, Litigation Release Nos. 14591 (Aug. 7, 1995), 59 SEC Docket 3105 (Sept. 5, 1995), and 14616 (Aug. 24, 1995), 60 SEC Docket 122 (Sept. 19, 1995). 17 SEC v, Spencer, Litigation Release Nos. 14856 (Mar. 29, 1996), 61 SEC Docket 1960 (Apr. 30, 1996), and 15042 (Sept. 12, 1996), 62 SEC Docket 2409 (Oct. 8, 1996). 18 SEC v. Wye Resources, Inc., Litigation Release No. 15073 (Sept. 26, 1996), 62 SEC Docket 2762 (Oct. 22, 1996). 19 SEC v. Frye, Litigation Release Nos. 14720 (Nov. 15, 1995), 60 SEC Docket 2123 (Dec. 12, 1995), 15139 (Oct. 29, 1996), 63 SEC Docket 422 (Nov. 26, 1996). 20 SEC v. Sellin, Litigation Release No. 15012 (Aug. 12, 1996), 62 SEC Docket 1749 (Sept. 10, 1996). 21 SEC v.Octagon Tech. Group. Inc., Litigation Release No. 14942 (June 11, 1996), 62 SEC Docket 377 (July 9, 1996). 22 See discussion at pp. 14-15.
III. The Commission's Program to Prevent
Fraud in the Micro Cap Markets
The Commission's program to prevent fraud in the micro cap market involves:
- early detection and intervention; and
- investor education.
A. Early Detection and Intervention
The Commission's program of early detection and intervention includes: (1) regular examination of broker-dealers; (2) surveillance of the Internet and the markets; (3) imposition of trading suspensions; and ( 4) an increasing resort to emergency litigation to stop active and on-going frauds.
The Commission's Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations ( "OCIE ") examines broker-dealers and oversees the examinations which the Self Regulatory Organizations ( "SROs ") -- the national securities exchanges and the NASD -- conduct of their members. Over the past several years, OCIE has focused its review of broker-dealers on their sales and trading practices. About 20% of examinations lead to referrals to the Commission's Division of Enforcement. OCIE is currently working closely with the NASD to focus on micro cap fraud through intense examination of broker-dealers.
The examination staff also periodically conducts "sweeps " to determine if particular violations are widespread and then it issues recommendations and reports. For instance, in 1994 the Commission staff with the NYSE and NASD conducted a review of the hiring, retention and supervisory practices of nine of the largest brokerage firms. Two years later, the Commission, together with the NASD, NYSE and the North American Securities Administrators Association, Inc. ( "NASAA ") conducted a joint sweep to review the sales practices of selected registered representatives employed by small and medium-sized firms as well as the hiring, retention and supervisory practices of the brokerage firms that employ them.
The second sweep revealed that some firms employ registered representatives with a history of disciplinary actions and customer complaints, use only minimal hiring procedures, and have supervisors in branch offices who fail to review customer transactions adequately to detect sales abuses. We also found that almost one-half of the branches that engage in cold calling violated federal cold-calling rules. 23 As a result of the sweep, the Commission, NYSE, NASD and NASAA prepared a public report making specific recommendations designed to correct these problems. 24 For example, the report recommends more stringent hiring procedures for registered representatives; heightened supervision of registered representatives with a history of customer complaints, disciplinary actions or arbitrations; and training and supervision of cold-calling techniques. 23 In 1991, Congress passed the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, Pub. L. No. 102243, 105 Stat. 2394 (1991), codified at 47 U.S.C. 227. The Federal Communications Commission enacted rules which, among other things, restrict the hours unsolicited calls can be made and require telemarketing firms to have "do-not-call " lists. 47 C.F.R. 64.1200. 24 Joint Regulatory Sales Practice Sweep, A Review of the Sales Practice Activities of Selected Registered Representatives and the Hiring, Retention, and Supervisory Practices of the Brokerage Finns Employing Them (Mar. 1996).
These joint sweeps have resulted in greater coordination among the regulatory authorities. The Commission's compliance staff meets quarterly with the NASD and NYSE to discuss how to improve our combined examination procedures. In addition, the Commission's regional examination staff meet regularly with their state counterparts and local NASD offices to determine how to better craft regulatory solutions.
To combat securities fraud on the Internet, the Commission's Division of Enforcement, with the assistance of other Commission staff, has assembled a group of professionals who devote more and more resources to Internet surveillance. These professionals use the latest browsing software to monitor the Internet, including such message areas as newsgroups and bulletin boards. The on-line Division of Enforcement Complaint Center also provides an easy means for investors to send complaints to the Commission staff. Currently, the Commission receives between 50 and 70 on-line investor complaints a day. Suspicious activities are investigated, with enforcement action initiated where appropriate. In addition, the Commission staff has helped states develop their own Internet surveillance programs and meets regularly with the states, both individually and as part of regional and national conferences, to coordinate our surveillance and investigations.
The Commission recently implemented a pilot program in our Florida regional office to intervene as soon as a potential sham micro cap offering is identified, which has already resulted in six trading suspensions. 25 The staff reviews regulatory filings for irregularities, or "red flags ", that suggest the company may not be legitimate. After determining that the public interest and protection of investors require it, the Commission can suspend trading in the stock. Trading suspensions can be a very potent remedy because: 25 In the Matter of Amquest International, Ltd.. Exchange Act Release No. 38695 (May 30, 1997), 64 SEC Docket 1862 (July 1, 1997); In the Matter of Green Oasis Environmental, Inc., Exchange Act Release No. 38588 (May 9, 1997), 64 SEC Docket 1395 (June 10, 1997); In the Matter of Genesis International Financial Services, Inc., Exchange Act Release No. 38565 (May 1, 1997), 64 SEC Docket 1259 (May 27, 1997); In the Matter of Historic Hotel Holdings, Inc., Exchange Act Release No. 38492 (Apr. 10, 1997), 64 SEC Docket 761 (May 6, 1997); In the Matter of OmniGene Diagnostics, Inc., Exchange Act Release No. 37966 (Nov. 19, 1996), 63 SEC Docket 709 (Dec. 17, 1996); In the Matter of Home Link Corp., Inc., Exchange Act Release No. 37292 (June 10, 1996), 62 SEC Docket 288 (July 9, 1996).
- Investors are put on notice of a potential fraud, hopefully encouraging more informed decision- making; and
- Promoters and brokers are hit where it hurts most: in the pocketbook. The financial reward of a micro cap scheme depends on selling all the stock at the height of the manipulation. A trading suspension often leaves the promoters holding worthless stock before they are able to dump it on unsuspecting investors.
Although a trading suspension only halts trading for a ten- day period, the suspension triggers application of Exchange Act Rule 150-11, which requires a market maker to have current and accurate financial information about the issuer before trading resumes. In other words, it is difficult for a broker-dealer to lawfully resume trading.
B. Investor Education
The Commission continually works to educate investors about how to avoid and report securities fraud through its Office of Investor Education and Assistance (OIEA). A well-educated investor is one of the most important defenses against securities fraud. Through Investor Alerts, an Internet Web Site 26 and a toll-free information line, 27 OIEA provides investors with practical tips on how to spot securities fraud. Numerous pamphlets and brochures have been developed to warn investors about scams, stating in "plain English " what every investor should know about investing. All of our publications are available free of charge on the Commission's website as well as through our toll free number. 26 sec.gov 27 ( 800) SEC-0330
To educate investors and listen to their concerns, the Commission has coordinated -and will continue to hold -- Investors' Town Meetings throughout the country. The town meetings are typically well |