To: neolib who wrote (520471 ) 11/8/2012 8:08:47 PM From: Bridge Player 8 Recommendations Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 793622 How much of the growth in the Chinese economy in the last 5-10 years is based on stuff like this? Hard to believe that you are sincere in a statement (paraphrasing) that proper accounting for both the U.S. and China would lead to a conclusion that their GDP has already passed the U.S. What total nonsense. Shopping center half again as large as the Mall of America in Minnesota, sitting nearly totally empty. No retailers with the economic incentive to open there. Nine million people living within 12 miles of the place, apparently without the income necessary to make the place a success. Photos Why This Huge Chinese Mall Is Empty Kaid Benfield Mar 30, 2012 Courtesy: Remko Tanis/Flickr In this space, I have written before about dead shopping malls, past their prime and doomed by a business model stuck in the late 20th century . Although I am no fan of the architectural form or the way malls became de facto , mass-manufactured, neo-public spaces (while being vastly inferior to true public spaces) in American suburbs, there can be something profoundly sad when they fail . Courtesy: Remko Tanis /Flickr The giant mall you see in the photos here, though, didn’t die. It has never lived, having been nothing but empty since it opened seven years ago. According to its Wikipedia entry , it has an astounding 2,350 available retail spaces, only 47 of which are occupied. Courtesy: Remko Tanis /Flickr Courtesy: Jason Fung /Flickr Meet the world’s largest shopping mall, the New South China Mall in Dongguan, China. It is twice as big as the huge Mall of America outside Minneapolis. Super-talented photographer Matthew Niederhauser describes the mall on his blog : A local billionaire built it, and they did not come. The South China Mall was the most ambitious and largest retail space ever conceived in China, if not the world, when it opened in 2005. Constructed smack in the middle of the Pearl River Delta between Shenzhen and Guangzhou, about 4 million people live within six miles of it, 9 million within twelve miles and 40 million within sixty miles. Nonetheless, six years later, the South China Mall only maintains a 1% occupancy rate at best. This unabatedly empty temple to consumerism remains unfinished on top floors and is only sporadically visited thanks to the attached amusement park, Amazing World. For the time being dust and dismembered mannequins reign over the 6.5 million square foot venture. Although China might be the fastest growing consumer market in the world, the South China Mall reveals the vulnerability of this burgeoning economic giant. ww.theatlanticcities.com/jobs-and-economy/2012/03/why-huge-chinese-mall-empty/1637/ This article is 9 months old, so I suppose it is always possible that development within the mall has begun. But that seems an unlikely prospect.Go visit a modern Chinese city, then come back and find a comparable one in the USA. Then write a report on American Exceptionalism. You love to denigrate American exceptionalism, like most liberals. With no acceptance of the basic facts....that freedom (which you do claim to admire), capitalism (not the phony crony type that goes on so much today), free markets, open competition, limited government and limited regulation, low taxation, a spirit of entrepreneurialism, and Constitutional originalism, have all combined to create a country to which tens of millions aspire to come to, believing that they can succeed here through their own efforts, and a country which is in the process of being destroyed by (to use just one simple example) philosophies such as, to recover from fiscal problems caused by too much debt and spending, we must increase further our spending. I know. It's a lousy sentence. But I am so pissed that I really can't write very well tonight.