SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : View from the Center and Left -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Sam who wrote (247334)3/12/2014 11:12:10 PM
From: JohnM  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 541735
 
I've never seen all that put together so forcefully. I was aware of each of those items and didn't care enough about the conversation here to drop one or two in. Which was all that popped to mind. But your list is the best I've seen. All of it together. In one place. A very large tip of the hat, sir.

If there was ever a longish version of refrigerator pasting material, this post is certainly it.



To: Sam who wrote (247334)3/13/2014 7:44:05 AM
From: koan  Respond to of 541735
 
Come on Sam, you know everything is relative. The first lights of civilization were only turned on about 700 BC. We know next to nothing before then. It was dark. We were still functioning pretty much as animals and engaged in killing and even cannibalism matter of factly. The concept of Democracy was not even in our heads yet.

The ancient Greeks were planting the first seeds of civilization e.g. Republics, indeed just plain old thinking and ideas. So we cannot expect much except as it relates to everything else humans were doing at the time.

By 400/500 BC the Ancient Greeks had thought up concepts more intellectually sophisticated than anything we saw for almost 2,000 years after their destruction, including no big thinkers to compare with so many of the great Greek thinkers. Too many to list.

None I could ever find. If they are out there I would be curious to know who they were. Even the great Marcus Aurelius was mediocre, IMO, compared to any of the great Greeks; and he was about as good as humans produced until the Age of Enlightenment.

We are still torturing and killing people for no reason and yawning at it e.g. Viet Nam and Iraq. But at least we don't condone slavery or cannibalism.

I was only measuring the level of sophisticated thought the ancient Greeks exhibited. Not the success of the societies. That has been dismal until the good old USA came into being.

<<
Good grief, Koan--the Athenians exiled Thucydides, Xenophon and Euripides, they killed Socrates for allegedly teaching the young subversive ideas, and Plato was always on the outs with mainstream Athens society, writing his Socratic dialogues as his only means of protesting against their continued injustices. Aristotle fled from Athens, leaving the school he had founded years earlier, saying that he wouldn't let them sin against philosophy yet another time (killing yet another philosopher). Sophocles was put on trial for mental incompetence as a 90 year old man because his son got tired of waiting for him to die, although fortunately he was not committed--supposedly he read parts of Oedipus at Colonus at the trial, the last play of his Oedipus trilogy. They fought a devastating war for nearly 40 years with Sparta, where a quarter or more of their population died either in battle or due to sickness. They were a slave society, where a quarter to a third of their citizens were enslaved (OK, not their citizens, because slaves couldn't citizens, but they weren't even 3/5 of a person in Athens, lol), and they had an empire where they effectively enslaved other societies as well, forcing them to pay tribute that they couldn't really afford, and using parts of their population as slaves in Athens. Athens and Sparta were both pretty much hated and feared around the Mediterranean world that came into contact with them.

This is the society that you love so much?