News Corp.'s Satellite TV Venture Makes Strong Inroads in China interactive.wsj.com By FARA WARNER Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
HONG KONG -- Rupert Murdoch's News Corp. is back in favor in China, quietly insinuating itself into the nation's growing television industry.
The company's relationship to Beijing grew chilly in 1993, after Mr. Murdoch, its chairman and chief executive, proclaimed that satellite television would undermine totalitarian regimes.
But now a satellite-TV venture called Phoenix, partly owned by News Corp., is making gains in China -- where it's downplaying its links to Mr. Murdoch. Phoenix has put News Corp. "in a position in China that any international broadcaster would love," says John Wong of Boston Consulting Group International Ltd., who advises media companies in China.
To get back in China's good graces, News Corp. had to change its rhetoric and adopt an uncharacteristically low profile. "There's no use bullying your way into a deal, and that's taken us a long time to figure out," says Gary Davey, chief executive of News Corp.'s Hong Kong-based Star TV unit.
As concern mounts about Asia's stability and the wisdom of building businesses there, News Corp.'s low-profile, long-haul approach to China provides an intriguing model. The centerpiece of its strategy is Phoenix, a 24-hour satellite-TV channel aimed at China that is 45%-owned by Star.
News Corp. had first tried to set up ventures with China's national broadcaster, China Central Television. But when that approach failed, Star teamed up with Today's Asia Ltd., a media company with ties to mainland China, which took a 45% stake, and China Wise International Ltd., an international sales and advertising agent for China's TV stations, which got the other 10%.
News Corp.'s timing was superb. Phoenix started broadcasting from Hong Kong in March 1996, at the same time that China's television industry was growing rapidly, with hundreds of cable networks popping up starved for programming. As the demand rose, the cable operators started plucking channels like Phoenix from the sky, making Phoenix an increasingly desirable ad vehicle. The channel now claims a potential viewership in China of more than 36 million homes.
China remains a tightly controlled media market, and it is still grappling with how to open its economy while still maintaining social and political control over its people. And squeezed by Asia's raging financial turmoil and by domestic woes such as a shaky banking system, China faces a slowdown in its spectacular growth rate.
Still, there are early signs of success for Phoenix. Last month it hosted a sales presentation for ad executives at Beijing's Great Hall of the People. Industry sources say the event gleaned pledges for $34 million of air time on the channel. That's double the pledges made in 1996, media buyers say. Star's vice president for Phoenix advertising sales, Peggy Lam, says by early December $4 million had already come in.
To maintain good relations with China, News Corp. continues to do a "lot of work at the political level in China," Star's Mr. Davey says. For example, he says, he visits the mainland about 20 times a year, and Mr. Murdoch also makes frequent trips to the region. In July, during Hong Kong's handover to China, Mr. Murdoch made the rounds as a guest of the territory's new chief executive, Tung Chee Hwa.
And News Corp. doesn't just talk. In 1994 it dropped the British Broadcasting Corp. from the collection of channels it beams into China because the Chinese didn't like a program the BBC ran on Mao Tse-tung. The same year, a News Corp. unit published a flattering biography of Deng Xiaoping, written by his youngest daughter, Deng Rong. (A spokeswoman for HarperCollins says "the proposal for the book came in through normal channels" and was approved "on its merits.")
Phoenix's success also owes something to how far Mr. Murdoch and News Corp. stay out of the business. "We never mention Star or News Corp.," says a former Phoenix executive. "Phoenix is meant to be seen as a channel controlled by Chinese." Indeed, Phoenix's chairman and chief executive officer is Liu Chang Le, a Singaporean businessman associated with Asia's Today. Phoenix and Mr. Liu provide "an interesting bridge between [an international media company] and China," says Mr. Davey.
Phoenix's programming is also controlled by the Chinese partners, says the former Star executive. "It's all supposed to be positive and avoid political issues." Although Phoenix runs "NYPD Blue" late Sunday night, a significant portion of the programming is localized and relatively innocuous, including "Perfect Match," a takeoff on dating-game programs.
Mr. Davey disputes the idea that Phoenix doesn't air challenging programs. He points out that during the Hong Kong handover, Phoenix aired the British part of the ceremonies and China Central Television didn't. "That does prove our credentials," he says.
An audience survey conducted for Phoenix last year by China Mainland Marketing Research Co. showed that TV viewers in China were aware Phoenix could offer something different from official channels and that about 28% of them said they watched Phoenix occasionally to find out what was going on in Hong Kong and Taiwan.
One obstacle for Phoenix: It's still technically illegal for the country's approximately 1,200 cable operators to transmit foreign broadcasting to the nation's estimated 55 million cable homes. Just how that ban affects Phoenix has been a little murky.
In early September, mainland Chinese newspapers began reporting that Phoenix had "official" status -- or licensing agreements to provide programs -- on some of Guangdong Province's cable systems. That gave Phoenix distribution in about 2.5 million homes, according to Mr. Davey.
But officially at least, the Ministry of Radio, Film and Television takes a different view. The ministry "has never approved the broadcasting of the Phoenix Chinese Channel on either television stations or cable stations," states Wei Zhangjua, a ministry official, in response to questions from The Wall Street Journal.
-- S. Karene Witcher in Sydney, Australia, contributed to this article. |