To: THE ANT who wrote (109494 ) 1/5/2015 12:11:36 AM From: elmatador Respond to of 219974 QE will fail to revive the eurozone economy, according to economists polled in a Financial Times survey. QE is not a panacea for the euro-area,” said Carsten Brzeski of ING DiBa, a bank. He suggested that the biggest impact from any QE would come “if governments were at the same time allowed to start a deficit-financed investment programme. The FT survey of 32 eurozone economists, mainly working in the financial sector, conducted in mid-December, found most expected the ECB to launch QE in 2015 — catching up with the world’s other main central banks that have all bought large quantities of sovereign debt since the last financial crisis. Twenty-six economists forecast the central bank would start purchasing government bonds this year, while five thought it would not. One did not respond to the question. A stuttering recovery and a worrying drop in inflation have raised fears of another financial crisis in the currency bloc and put pressure on policy makers to cast aside powerful opposition from Germany and begin purchasing sovereign debt. ECB president Mario Draghi last week gave his strongest signal yet that the central bank would extend its asset purchases to include sovereign debt in the next few months. A decision could come as early as the next governing council meeting on January 22. But most of the FT poll’s respondents expected growth and inflation to remain weak even with quantitative easing. “[QE] will help lift inflation expectations and reduce the euro, but [it’s] not a total game changer,” said Dario Perkins, economist at Lombard Street Research. Jörg Krämer of Commerzbank said QE would lower the yield on government bonds and “help the finance ministries of highly indebted countries such as Italy, and its banks”. But he added that QE would not change low growth and inflation levels and would “only fuel asset prices”. While several respondents said government bond-buying was likely to help fight the threat of deflation and lower yields on debt issued by weaker sovereigns, most economists agreed that growth would remain lacklustre unless governments backed the ECB’s efforts. “QE is not a panacea for the euro-area,” said Carsten Brzeski of ING DiBa, a bank. He suggested that the biggest impact from any QE would come “if governments were at the same time allowed to start a deficit-financed investment programme. [It’s] doubtful [that] will ever happen in the euro area.” Some said a larger package stood more chance of success. “If it is big enough, it will have some effect on the economy, if only to bring the euro down,” said Jonathan Loynes of research group Capital Economics. “It’s worth a try.” Of the economists who put a number on the size of the purchases, the most popular guess was €500bn, although some put the figure as high as €1tn and others as low as €250bn. Some also expected the ECB to start buying corporate debt alongside sovereign bonds. Eurozone inflation dropped to 0.3 per cent in November, less than a fifth of the ECB’s target of just below 2 per cent. Inflation is likely to have fallen again in December on the back of the sharp drop in oil prices. Mr Draghi and most of the governing council backed a new development in ECB policy in December, saying the expansion of the central bank’s balance sheet from €2tn towards the €3tn mark was now expected. However, six policy makers objected to the December decision, underlining the extent of divisions over quantitative easing. Jens Weidmann, the Bundesbank’s president, was among the dissenters, and while Berlin is not expected publicly to oppose the policy, resistance within Germany remains fierce. Many economists think it is impossible for the ECB to hit the €3tn level by confining its purchases to the assets it buys at the moment: covered bonds and asset-backed securities. “The ECB will purchase sovereign debt in 2015, mostly for want of anything else to buy,” said Lorcan Roche Kelly of Agenda Research. Twenty-six respondents to the FT’s poll thought the size of the ECB’s balance sheet would lie somewhere between €2tn and €3tn by the end of 2015. Two thought the ECB would be able to hit €3tn over the next 12 months, while four thought the balance sheet would fall below €2tn. Some respondents thought resistance within the council could affect the programme, with others suggesting the ECB would ensure national central banks bore the risk from buying their governments’ bonds. “The ECB will most probably have to limit sovereign purchases to investment grade sovereigns,” said Hetal Mehta of Legal & General Investment Management, an insurer. “The purchases will consist of nationally-weighted sovereign [debt purchases]. I think that [credit] risk will probably [be] decentralised at the national level via some mechanism,” said Lucrezia Reichlin, a professor at London Business School and co-founder of data firm NowCasting. Richard Barwell of Royal Bank of Scotland said: “There may be compromises in the design to get as many people on board as possible, but I expect a sufficiently strong signal that the ECB is determined to do what it takes to preserve price stability and that’s what counts in the end.” Kit Juckes of Société Générale said buying European Investment Bank bonds to spur investment spending was a “more appealing” way for the ECB to spend its cash. Harald Benink, a professor at Tilburg University, agreed. “Our proposal of buying bonds?.?.?.?issued by the EIB is likely to be more acceptable to the Bundesbank since it is violating to a lesser extent monetary financing rules as contained in the [EU] Treaty”, he said. .?.?.Read the responses to the FT’s poll of eurozone economists Question 1: What is your growth forecast for the region’s economy over the next 12 months? Question 2: How low will inflation go in 2015? Question 3: What do you think eurozone policy makers need to do next to boost the region’s recovery? Question 4: Is the fiscal compact fit for purpose? Question 5: Will the European Central Bank embark on full-scale quantitative easing ? If so, what will the package look like? Question 6: Would government bond-buying by the European Central Bank work? Question 7: What size will the ECB’s balance sheet be by the end of 2015? Question 8: Will we see a sizeable fiscal stimulus from Germany? Question 9: Will the euro reach parity with the dollar in 2015? Related Topics European Central Bank , Europe Quantitative Easing