To: John Mansfield who wrote (8889 ) 1/14/1998 2:52:00 PM From: Mike Winn Respond to of 31646
>>>Sensory overload "This will be a far bigger issue on the plant floor than in a mainframe," said Bill Heermann, sales director at Tava Technologies, here. "In a mainframe, you've got software that's only looking at about five streams of data. On the plant floor, you've often got 10,000 electronic sensors, and in one fashion or another, each sensor is a data stream that has to be examined. One of those 10,000 sensors may begin feeding bad data to networked devices above them and bring down the whole network, shutting down the plant." LOL! Scare tactics for little kids at Halloween! First, why does electronic sensor have to worry about date? Then if a few of them do, you don't have to inspect every single one of them to isolate the problem because you must have an idea how your plant is laid out and where the date calculation is done. For instance if your car breaks down and you take it to an experienced auto mechanics, he/she does not need to inspect every single wire, valve, switch, gear, bolt, etc. in your car to diagnose the problem. An experienced mechanics can isolate the problem by cranking up the engine a couple of times, or take a few measurements. If you debug your software, do you look at every single line of code? If you fix a PC, do you take everything apart and inspect each piece? Do you know how many pieces of mechanical, electrical, electronics are there is a complex electric or nuclear plant, aircraft, chemical plant, etc. ? It's just economically impossible to inspect each piece. If Tava doesn't know how a plant operate, forget about hiring them to do the assessment or remediation because it's going to take forever. That kind of statement from the sales director of Tava tells me he doesn't know what he is talking about. This company is loosing money even doing regular factory automation work. Tava's only expertise is in making CDs.