Koan’s life mirrors and parallels that of Karl Marx, it’s the closest example of reincarnation I’ve ever encountered.
Karl Marx’s personal life was often chaotic, marked by chronic money problems, a mix of idealism and contradiction, and a temperament that veered between passionate commitment and frustration.
Personal Background Marx was born in 1818 in Trier, Prussia (now Germany), to a middle-class Jewish family that had converted to Lutheranism for social reasons. He married Jenny von Westphalen, a baron’s daughter, in 1843 — a loyal but difficult partnership strained by poverty, ill health, and exile. They had seven children, only three of whom survived to adulthood. Most of Marx’s adult life was spent in London, often in near destitution, supported financially by his lifelong collaborator and friend Friedrich Engels, who regularly sent him money from his earnings in his family’s textile business.
Gambling and Speculation Yes — Marx had a weakness for financial speculation and gambling, particularly on the stock market and in horse racing. He treated speculation as a kind of intellectual challenge, often writing in letters that he was trying to “beat the system.” His habits were notorious among his friends, who sometimes worried about his losses.
In 1864 he told Engels that he was “making money on the Stock Exchange” — he believed he could predict market movements based on his understanding of political economy. But in truth, he was not successful: he often lost money rather than gained it. Engels eventually warned him against it. Marx’s speculative ventures were less a source of wealth than a reflection of his restless temperament — he enjoyed the analytical thrill even though it contradicted his disdain for capitalism in theory.
Character and Contradictions Marx could be charming, witty, and deeply loyal to friends, but also abrasive, domineering, and self-righteous. He was prone to bohemian excess, chain-smoked cigars, and suffered from chronic liver ailments (likely exacerbated by overwork and stress). He also fathered a child out of wedlock with his housemaid, Helene Demuth, though Engels later took public responsibility for the child to protect Marx’s reputation.
Summary So, yes — Karl Marx did gamble and speculate, mainly on stocks and horse races, but he was not successful. His personal life was full of financial insecurity, family tragedy, and contradictions between his revolutionary ideals and his private behavior.
1. Marx’s admission of stock speculation Letter to Friedrich Engels, June 18, 1864
“I have been speculating, partly in American funds, but mainly in English stocks, which are bound to rise after the conclusion of peace... in this way I shall make money.”
Marx was referring to the American Civil War and betting that the end of the war would lift certain securities. He clearly believed his understanding of political economy gave him an edge — an ironic mirror of the capitalist mindset he was critiquing.
Engels, who was financially disciplined, warned him against it, knowing Marx’s temperament.
2. Engels’ exasperation with Marx’s losses Letter from Engels to Marx, November 1867
“You are incorrigible, old boy. You will not be content till you have gambled away your last penny again.”
Engels often ended up covering Marx’s debts — rent, pawnbrokers, school fees, and even the cost of food. The two joked darkly about Marx’s “speculative genius.”
3. Marx’s interest in horse racing In several letters, Marx mentions betting on horse races at the local tavern. One historian (Francis Wheen, Karl Marx: A Life) describes Marx spending hours studying racing forms and calculating odds, calling it a “theoretical exercise” in probability and market behavior — but he usually lost.
4. Self-awareness of his contradictions Letter to Engels, 1868:
“If you should hear that I have made a financial coup, don’t be alarmed. It will not be by honest labour, but by speculation.”
He clearly knew the irony: the man writing Das Kapital — the great critique of capital — was trying to play the market.
5. Engels’ affectionate but sharp rebuke Letter from Engels, 1868:
“You ought to be the last man to gamble on the Stock Exchange. It is a contradiction in terms: the socialist speculator.”
Summary Marx’s gambling and speculation were:- Habitual but not chronic — he did it in bursts when desperate for money.
- Intellectualized — he saw markets as puzzles to solve.
- Financially disastrous — he almost never profited.
- Morally inconsistent — and he knew it.
 |
