To: Peter Stern who wrote (7239 ) 3/8/1998 4:31:00 PM From: B.K. Ohneis Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 16892
Mr. Peter Stern: It appears that there is some interest in a comment from you on the following posting. Please grant us an audience! Thanks. ******************* To: Jon Tara (7268 ) From: B.K. Ohneis Sunday, Mar 8 1998 5:58AM EST Reply # of 7273 <<message from Jon Tara on Mar 8 1998 2:58AM EST I think that the new Datek equity calculation is entirely proper. Your equity is the amount that you would receive if you sold your portfolio immediately. Thus, the bid for longs, the offer for shorts. I strongly suspect that the NASD and SEC would agree with Datek's calculation. Sorry.>> thank you for your assertion but i was asking for the Datek formula for calculating margin interest. do you know how they do it? i agree with you if the equity calculation on the portfolio window has meaning only for the customer's equity in terms of how money he may still have. my question is, however, does that affect the amount of margin interest he has to pay, as a fellow asked in a previous posting. if you have no idea what that question is, here is a possible way that the calculation may have some effect: you bot 1000 EGRP at 25 and borrowed half of the money from Datek, say, 12500. now EGRP dropped to 20, your equity is now only 10000. your real cash in the portfolio window is -2500. your current purchasing power would be deducted by -2500 (is this correct or not? Mr. Peter Stern, please comment). the big question is, does the customer have to pay interest on this "-2500"? Does Datek think that it has lent 15000 to the customer? I understand that this drop of equity does not affect the purchasing power or margin interest of the customer in my other brokerage account, since the reduction in the customer's equity does not affect the money that the broker lent to the customer when the purchase was made. Of course, if the drop comes to the house call rule, then all hell will come. The Datek method of calculating purchasing power would reduce your purchasing when you send in new money to the account. say you send in 10000 now, your purchase power would not be 20000, but (20000-2500). this is not a good method for a long term investor, and that is way, i only sent in one quarter of my money to my Datek account. Actually, i believe some friends of mine also do the same. Datek is actually losing business because of this. Any comments, please, especially from Datek. Perhaps we should have been able to figure out how Datek is doing but i found no explanation in the statements i have received. the margin interest is billed as "Margin, $****", no explanation whatsoever. Other brokers tell me margin at __% on average balance of ___". the Datek number so appears to be from the black hole.