To: robnhood who wrote (9802 ) 4/12/1998 8:39:00 PM From: goldsnow Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 116762
Amid Japan gloom, some warn of too much pessimism 12:45 a.m. Apr 12, 1998 Eastern By Linda Sieg TOKYO, April 12 (Reuters) - Amidst the gloom which greeted Japan's latest effort to turn its economy around, a few people are warning that the real risk might be on the upside. ''It's like a 'Titanic' movie of packages,'' says Richard Jerram, chief economist at ING Barings in Tokyo of Japan's latest and biggest-ever batch of economic stimulus steps. ''It costs a fortune, it's widely expected to flop and in the end, it's surprisingly successful.'' Confidence in Japan's economy has been battered by a string of gloomy data in recent weeks, with some doomsayers warning the world's second-largest economy was on the brink of a 1930s-style Great Depression. Critics have dubbed Prime Minister Ryutaro Hashimoto the ''Herbert Hoover'' of Japan, opposition politicians touted a ''New Deal'' platform, and some pundits invoked the ghost of Franklin Delano Roosevelt adviser Harry Hopkins for guidance. Against that gloomy backdrop, financial markets were left longing for more after Hashimoto decided last week to put fiscal reform on hold and include an extra four trillion yen ($31.0 billion) in once-off income tax cuts in a package worth 10 trillion in fresh stimulus. Behind the pessimism is the belief that while Hashimoto's proposals will rescue Japan from recession and worse, the list of structural ills that needs to be cured is far too long. Among the Herculean tasks many agree must be carried out are broad tax reform including permanent income tax cuts and a speedier reduction of corporate taxes, faster deregulation and the creation of a leaner and more efficient government. Without those changes, such reasoning goes, the foundation for a sustainable recovery cannot be laid. ''Why are things so bad? Because there are not only cyclical factors, but also structural problems and those are getting worse,'' says Susumu Takahashi, a senior economist at Japan Research Institute, a private think-tank. ''It's not enough to just increase demand, the structural ills must also be cured.'' Few would deny that structural faults need to be fixed. But some warn that pessimism can feed on itself. ''People aren't giving them any credit for some of the things they are doing,'' says Larry Duke, a vice president at Citibank in Tokyo. ''I'm not saying that things are going to be booming, but there is potential for more positive growth than the markets expect. They are under-discounting the good news and over-discounting the bad news.'' ING Barings' Jerram argues that too many economists are extrapolating backwards from preconceived forecasts that the economy will not recover -- no matter what. ''Three months ago, the argument was the government won't spend money, so the economy won't recover. Two months ago, the argument was the government will spend money, but not enough. Two weeks ago, it was the government will spend a lot of money, but on the wrong things. Now the argument is they're cutting taxes, but the cuts aren't permanent,'' Jerram says. ''Obviously, there are structural problems, but that doesn't mean fiscal policy is ineffective and the economy never grows.'' Those prepared to look on the bright side point out that while Hashimoto hasn't promised permanent tax cuts, he hasn't ruled them out either. ''I think we could have given Hashimoto's proposals a somewhat higher grade,'' says Masatoshi Kikuchi, a senior market analyst at Daiwa Institute of Research. ''Hashimoto said tax reform would be discussed...and I think there will be more drastic reforms and permanent cuts emerging later in the year,'' Kikuchi added. Others, meanwhile, argue that a magnificent obsession with the admittedly massive problems of Japan's financial firms obscures the relative robustness of its manufacturers. ''Of course the financial industry is in bad shape,'' says Hajime Karatsu, a professor at Tokai University. ''But the financial industry is worth five percent of Japan's GDP (gross domestic product) while the manufacturing industry is worth 25 percent of GDP...and many manufacturers are very buoyant.'' The national financial daily Nihon Keizai Shimbun reported in its Friday evening edition that Hashimoto had said he might ask the government and the ruling Liberal Democratic Party to discuss the possibility of making the promised income tax permanent. ((Tokyo Newsroom +81-3 3432 8022 tokyo.newsroom+reuters.com)) ^MORE@ Copyright 1998 Reuters Limited.