To: Dennis R. Duke who wrote (1370 ) 4/13/1998 6:27:00 PM From: Dennis R. Duke Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1629
In this continuing He said She said, Alex Brown said "No Surprises in 1Q Results" and continues to rate ASND as a "Market Performer". EPS estimates are CY EPS 1.06 1.16 1.49, respectively. Their write up is as follows: HIGHLIGHTS: -- EPS were $0.26 on revenue of $305 million -- Moderate sequential growth across all product segments -- Future emphasis on international and core business growth -- ASP impact of triple density modem boards is uncertain -- Fine-tuning estimates, Maintaining "Market Perform" investment rating DETAILS: 1Q EPS were $0.26 on revenue of $305 million - Ascend announced 1Q results that were in-line with our revenue estimate, and a penny better than our EPS estimate of $0.25. The Company squeezed the extra $0.01 by reducing expenses more substantially than expected. Sales and marketing expenditures were $70.8 million, or 22.1% of revenue versus 23.8% last quarter. Research and development was 13.4% of revenue versus 13.8% in 4Q. However, due to increased hiring plans, R&D expense is expected to be significantly higher in 2Q. [Interest one calls the extra penny coming from only R&D delays, and this one notices the Sales and Marketing to contribute to that penny over, too. CC told us S&M costs are planned to be coming down.] Revenue was up 4% both sequentially and year/year. Management had cautioned analysts last quarter regarding 1Q's seasonal weakness, and that modest growth expectations were warranted. As in 4Q, North America was the strongest geographic market, while international revenues were off modestly to 26% of total sales. Ascend noted uniform strength across all segments of its carrier and ISP customers, and the book-to-bill was greater than 1. We believe the Company's core products most positively impacted the strong bookings, with activity focused on the new GX 550 ATM switch. However, the GX 550 did not contribute to revenue 1Q. [huh, did not say "revenue was not recognized.] [Details of revenue mix as given in my CC summary deleted] Service revenue was the only category that was down sequentially. Access revenues were driven by growth in North America and success with the company's MAX TNT product. Management also noted increased interest in DSL products during the quarter. Somewhat surprising was the strong performance of the Company's enterprise access business. This is comprised largely of low-end routers for ISDN and frame relay access. However, Ascend's high-end GRF routers continue to struggle in the market, and were off for the third consecutive quarter. Ascend did not break out specific figures for frame relay and ATM revenues, but commented that frame relay grew sequentially. We believe ATM was likely down sequentially off a very strong 4Q. Despite this weakness, we continue to believe that ATM's market fundamentals are strong, and represent the best opportunity for sustained growth. Future emphasis on international and core business growth -- Going forward, the Company is focused on two areas for growth acceleration: international expansion and core product business. While international sales have declined steadily as a percentage of revenue, Ascend plans to invest substantially in this area. The Company's plan is for international sales to represent 30% of total revenues by year-end 1998, and 40% at an unspecified point in the future. In addition, Ascend has steadily derived a greater and greater portion of its revenue from Core products, which it gained largely through the Cascade acquisition. We expect core products to surpass 50% of revenues by year-end. We note, however, that ATM has driven growth in this area almost exclusively for the past year. We caution investors that an unexpected downturn in ATM sales, due to lumpy carrier purchasing or other unforeseen reason, would have a devastating effect, in our view. ASP impact of triple density modem boards is uncertain -- Price competition in the access space was severe throughout most of 1997. The pricing environment has stabilized over the past two quarters, with only nominal ASP declines. We believe the introduction of double-density modem boards last fall were a principal reason for a step function decrease in price points, which in-turn muted access revenue growth. Ascend is planning to introduce next-generation, triple-density boards during the summer. The Company believes that this will have little impact to the pricing environment. However, given the precedence of higher-density boards adverse affect on pricing, we are decidedly more cautious. Conclusion Ascend met street expectations for the second consecutive quarter, after a disappointment in 3Q 1997. The stock has traded up in recent weeks, in anticipation of a solid quarter. Ascend delivered the goods, albeit at comparatively lower expectations. The Company reiterated its comfort with 1998 revenues of $1.4 billion and EPS of $1.15. Accordingly, we have only adjusted our 1998 estimates for 1Q results. However, we have slightly reduced our 1999 estimates to reflect conservatism regarding renewed price competition and revenue growth expectations. Due to the rise in the Company's stock price, the shares are presently trading at 34x our $1.16 1998 EPS estimate, and 27x our $1.49 1999 EPS estimate. These multiples are at the high-end of the range for comparable companies. We believe the Company is fairly valued, given the risk stemming from its somewhat inconsistent financial performance and limited revenue visibility. Therefore, we are maintaining our "market perform" rating. --------- A bit more conservative and expressing concern over ATM and triple density modem boards, and believes fair valued at the current time. Dennis