To: Fortney Veeble who wrote (308 ) 6/10/1998 6:40:00 PM From: Fortney Veeble Respond to of 10934
Merrill Lynch analyst Steven Milunovich started coverage of NTAP today with a near-term "Accumulate" and a long-term "Buy". His 12 month price objective is $43 (only 16% above today's price of $37). EPS estimates are in line with the existing consensus ($.85 for FY'99, a 45% YOY growth rate). In the ML system, "Buy" is as good as it gets (1 = buy, 2 = accumulate, 3 = neutral, 4 = reduce, 5 = sell). Other other analysts use different terminology, with a "strong buy" = 1 and "buy" = 2, ... While the near-term recommendation and the price target are tepid support for NTAP, ML has estimated earnings - and earnings growth - which are in line with the present consensus, which other analysts see as strongly positive for the stock. Perhaps most significant about ML's announcement is simply that they have started coverage of NTAP. This move by a major brokerage house should increase the visibility of Network Appliance. In the following, I have taken excerpts, some out of context, from the ML report: "NetApp is relatively undiscovered yet likely to become an important computer company, especially as investors recognize the importance of appliances. We are not more aggressive on the rating due to a temporarily declining operating margin and upcoming product transition. NetApp's strategy is to identify promising product categories, such as file serving and network caching, that rely on data access via mature protocols. Two major trends play in its favor - the demand for storage and emergence of simple appliances. One surprise is how profitable appliances can be (think Cisco)." "NetApp has a new mantra. The old was 'fast, simple, reliable.' That created a new data storage product category and put the company on the map. The next level is 'scalable, manageable, available.'" Under "Investment Risks," ML states: "There will be a product transition in F2Q. 'Product transition' is a dirty phrase to technology investors. NetApp undergoes a product transition roughly every 15 months. New technology is introduced that results in a 25% price cut to users. We expect major new products offering a 50% performance increase to be announced in the October quarter." Under "Valuation," ML states: "The company is a category leader. NetApp looks like the winner in dedicated file servers. If the company executes, NetApp will gain increasing investor sponsorship and be one of the best names to own in the server segment." "The stock looks fairly valued on a statistical analysis. We do think, however, that consensus estimates (including ours) have a good chance of being conservative."