To: donss who wrote (3284 ) 5/21/1998 8:18:00 PM From: donss Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 10852
CIA Says Satellite Launchers, Missiles Nearly Identical [From the WSJ IE] WASHINGTON (AP)--Amid persistent questions about whether U.S. firms provided missile technology to China, a Senate panel released CIA information Thursday underscoring similarities between Chinese satellite launchers and long-range nuclear missiles. Staging mechanisms, guidance systems, re-entry vehicles, and rocket motors all involve identical or similar technology, the CIA said in a rare public disclosure of intelligence that it supplies to congressional committees. What emerged Thursday were releasable portions of a broader, classified briefing the CIA gave Senate investigators on Chinese missile and space launch capability last week. Weeks earlier, the CIA provided top officials with a classified assessment saying that 13 of China's intercontinental ballistic missiles are targeted at U.S. cities. Congressional Republicans are opening investigations into concerns that a satellite export approved by President Clinton this year for a company headed by a major Democratic donor may have aided China's missile programs. Administration critics say the similarity between satellite launch vehicles and ICBMs increases the chances that Clinton's export decisions may have led to the disclosure of valuable military technology. The administration counterattacked on multiple fronts. "No controlled information relative to ballistic missiles or warhead delivery technology has been authorized to be made available to Chinese authorities," said State Department spokesman James Rubin. "The whole underlying suggestion that somehow we want to transfer technology to the Chinese ... is simply fatuous." Investigations of the export license deal are under way both on Capitol Hill and at the Justice Department. The Justice probe focuses whether U.S. trade policy may have been affected by campaign fund raising. In Hong Kong Thursday, Liu Chaoying, the aerospace executive at the center of an alleged Chinese plot to influence the Clinton administration's foreign policy, denied a charge by a Democratic fund-raiser that she donated $300,000 to the Democratic Party. Liu is the daughter of retired Gen. Liu Huaqing, once China's most politically influential military officer. Republicans seeking a link between political donations and Clinton's national security and export decisions, have called on the president to postpone his trip to China next month. The White House reacted Thursday to a vote in the House to block future U.S. satellite exports to China and to prohibit Clinton from reaching new agreements while in China on sharing space technology. White House spokesman Mike McCurry called the House votes of Wednesday a "knee-jerk reaction to headlines rather than a thoughtful assessment of foreign policy." He also said the votes represented "a stunning repudiation" of policies of the Reagan and Bush administrations. A CIA chart released Thursday by the Senate Governmental Affairs international security subcommittee, which is investigating the issue, indicated that only one aspect of a rocket - the payload - differs substantially between civilian satellite launchers and nuclear weapons-tipped missiles. In other respects they are identical or similar: -Re-entry vehicles would operate similarly whether the object was a commercial capsule carrying such things as photographs and data or a nuclear weapon. -Payload separation from the rocket would involve similar procedures for a satellite or nuclear weapons. -Inertial guidance and control systems would use "similar hardware with tailored software." -Staging mechanisms, rocket propellants, air frame and motor cases, insulation and liners, engines or rocket motors, and thrust vector controls would be the same. -Exhaust nozzles are "similar and usually identical." "It is important to understand how foreign countries can apply information and technology gained from launching U.S. satellites to their own ICBM and satellite programs, and whether the administration's current policy is sufficient to prevent this," said Sen. Thad Cochran, R-Miss., the subcommittee's chairman. Additional CIA briefing papers not made public by Senate investigators but obtained Thursday by The Associated Press point to other differences between ICBMs and satellite launchers. ICBMs must be more rugged and more easily maintained because they are designed to sit in silos for long periods, according to the CIA material. "Instruments such as gyros and accelerometers adequate for a (satellite) space-launch vehicle might not be good enough for an ICBM," the CIA briefing paper stated. In addition, a satellite launcher "does not necessarily have to control satellite release to as tight a tolerance" as an ICBM. In 1996, Loral Space & Communications Ltd. (LOR) and Hughes Electronics (GMH) hired a government-owned Chinese rocket manufacturer to launch a commercial satellite into space. Under U.S. export laws, the satellite itself would not be handled by the Chinese. But when the rocket exploded, the Pentagon says, Loral and Hughes provided China with an accident assessment that contained valuable missile-related information. Republicans want to know why, with a Justice Department probe still pending, Clinton this February approved another satellite export by Loral, and whether the generous Democratic donations by Loral board chairman Bernard Schwartz had anything to do with the decision. The administration and Loral both deny any such allegation. Witnesses at Thursday's hearing supported the CIA's conclusions about the similarity of ICBMs and satellite launchers. "The essential elements of an ICBM are the same with the exception of the payload," said William Graham, former deputy administrator of NASA and science adviser to Presidents Reagan and Bush. "Put another way, if you have a space-launch vehicle, you also have an ICBM." But John Pike, director of space policy for the Federation of American Scientists, said it was naive to think China gained much from U.S. firms. China has had missiles that could reach the U.S. since 1981, and newly acquired information would make only a marginal difference, he said.