To: Scott C. Lemon who wrote (690 ) 6/3/1998 8:27:00 AM From: Frank A. Coluccio Respond to of 3178
Scott, your reply is indeed a welcome one here, and I thoroughly enjoyed the overlapping, contrasting and in some cases directly opposing views. You certainly are well prepared to engage such a discussion, and I feel that we can both learn something here. At the end of the day, if I am the one to walk home with the most new information, I'll be prepared to thank you in spades. I began immediately responding, and then took a look at the clock and considered all of the factors that were running in the background of my mind, and decided to defer to a later time. I can see where some statements I've (and you've) made are really contingent on whether or not the caching model is used in an autonomous manner, or one in which it is used in a highly orchestrated one. The latter, it would seem to me (unless I am dating myself again) is counter-intuitive to the Internet ethos, since chaos would dictate otherwise. However, before I concede any of my previous points [ which, in retrospect, could have been written with more safeguards built in ;-) ], I'd like an opportunity to analyze some of the precepts you've laid down, and prepare some counter-arguments where I think they are warranted, something I think you will agree is not a trivial undertaking. If, while we pursue this, we can keep VoIP and other deterministic- like requirements in the back of the mind, such as VoIP and multi-cast bidirectional conferencing, and other applications demanding of real-time network attributes, it will help keep the discussion relevant here, or at least demonstrate the influences that caching has on peripheral network expectations. I've got a little posting to do elsewhere before hitting the silica mines this morning, and would like an opportunity to address your reply later on today, or beyond. Until then, best regards, and thanks for this most professionally done contribution to the thread, which is another example of keeping discussions here 'above the line.' Later, Frank Coluccio