To: Thomas Haegin who wrote (4211 ) 6/5/1998 5:37:00 AM From: Thomas Haegin Respond to of 9980
Repost: Analyst/investor comments on Indonesia debt deal Reuters Story - June 04, 1998 14:54 ÿÿÿ LONDON, June 4 (Reuters) - Indonesia reached agreement on Thursday with international banks on the rescheduling of its external debt. ÿÿ The rescheduling programme comprises three initiatives relating to private sector corporate debt, external credit to the Indonesian banking system and trade finance. ÿÿ Analysts' and investors' reactions to the deal follow. ÿÿÿ ASHOK SHAH, SENIOR PORTFOLIO MANAGER, OLD MUTUAL ASSET MANAGEMENT, LONDON ÿÿÿ "Things are so bad now with non-payment of interest that even this programme is just a small part of a large programme that is needed. On its own it won't be enough. For Indonesia as a country and Indonesian companies, their ability to repay debt will be damaged for some time." ÿÿ "The numbers of debt outstanding are changing all the time, some of the banks have lied about it, they overvalued their assets by one-third. A lot still needs to come out of the woodwork." ÿÿ "It's very very positive that they've started (dealing with their debt problems) but they have a long way to go. Things were so deplorable that without help the whole thing would have imploded. I say well done but we need a lot more." ÿÿÿ JEROME BOOTH, HEAD OF EMERGING MARKET RESEARCH AT ANZ INVESTMENT BANK, LONDON ÿÿÿ "I think it is very positive. I would expect this to actually boost the market over time. Clearly, it signals that we could get further deals on corporate debt and basically it is good news. I don't think it's fully been reflected so far in the prices. The main focus now has got to be to see the debt restructuring in not just the banks but also with the corporates come to a conclusion and we have to see the Indonesians co-operating fully with the IMF." ÿÿÿ PHILIP EHRMANN, GARTMORE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LONDON ÿÿÿ "Its progress of a sort, but we'll have to watch this space...The devil is in the detail." ÿÿ "We had heard that it might be an eight year programme so obviously four is probably better. But I think that just the fact that they are attempting to sort out this problem is progress, but there still is a long way to go." ÿÿÿ SANJIT MAITRA, HEAD OF ECONOMICS AND STRATEGY, WEST LB, LONDON ÿÿÿ "It is certainly encouraging news and will help to resolve one of the most pressing issue in the region. It's a helpful sign in the right direction but it's not sufficient because of all the structural problems that remain." ÿÿÿ ANDY TAN, GENERAL MANAGER OF STANDARD & POORS/MMS, SINGAPORE: ÿÿÿ "It is a very important development. My personal feeling is that the debt restructuring issue should have been settled, it should have been on the priority list. Right now there is some progress here and that's a good sign. It's a step in the right direction but we are not expecting a dramatic pick-up in terms of sentiment. Too much water has passed under the bridge and it will take a while for confidence to return." ÿÿÿ On terms of the loans, at margins over LIBOR: "I don't think you can consider it to be unreasonable because there is a high risk premium attached to the loan. It's fair pricing." ÿÿÿ BRUCE GALE, ANALYST WITH POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC RISK CONSULTANCY LTD, SINGAPORE: ÿÿÿ "This agreement is helping Indonesia to hold together some of its (problems) which is a good thing, but on the other hand you've got a move against Suharto's business interests which has the potential to damage the economy from another directon. And you have the government itself running out of money. There probably has to be some government talks with the banks on their position." ÿÿÿ "The political situation is not stable. We could very well find ourselves with hyper-inflation, so this is not a formula for political stability. There are many ways this agreement could be overtaken by events in the next few months, just in the same way as the IMF agreements were overtaken by events." ÿÿÿ WILLIAM KEELING, HEAD OF RESEARCH, DRESDNER-KLEINWORT BENSON, JAKARTA ÿÿÿ "The conditions of the restructuring package are as much predicated upon the need of international banks to provision these losses over an eight-year period as they are in any belief that Indonesian corporates are going to be able to service these loans or repay them. ÿÿÿ "It provdes some relief to the cash flow of major Indonesian companies. But many, many companies will simply be unable to service the interest requirement let alone the ability to repay principal. Therefore, it relieves the situation but doesn't remove the burden, which must be regarded as fair. ÿÿÿ "The most important implications are not for Indonesia but what this means to the quality of loans outstanding and how this is perceived by banks that have exposure to countries with similar risk characteristics. We need to look at China and Russia and Eastern Europe. For those countries, both the cost and accessibility of new credits from international banks has to be open to question." ÿÿÿ HARUN HAJADI, PRESIDENT DIRECTOR OF CIPUTRA DEVELOPMENT , INDONESIAN PROPERTY COMPANY, JAKARTA ÿÿÿ "The next three years will still be difficult because of the magnitude of the current crisis. But two years after that would likely be a recovery period. So we need at least five years. With a period of eight years, companies should be able to survive. ÿÿÿ "But I had hoped the deal would provide the best real average market rate of six month not 20-days. ÿÿÿ SETYAWAN SULISTIYONO, SPOKESMAN FOR INDONESIAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS GIANT TELKOM , JAKARTA ÿÿÿ "I hope the debt roll over may help Telkom's partners under the joint-operation KSO scheme which have suffered from large forex losses. ÿÿÿ "Actually the debt roll over doesn't have direct impact for Telkom because most of the loans obtained by the company were two-step loans," the official said. He said Telkom received foreign loans through the government and the state bore the burden on forex losses. REUTERS <eom>