SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Biotech / Medical : VVUS: VIVUS INC. (NASDAQ) -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Frostman who wrote (9247)6/5/1998 6:24:00 PM
From: DaiS  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 23519
 
Frostman,

I am embarrassed to say that I made an error. I just realised that the numbers do not add up in step 1. Sorry, I have to look again - can anyone see the problem.

DaiS



To: Frostman who wrote (9247)6/5/1998 7:01:00 PM
From: DaiS  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 23519
 
Frostman or anyone, below is the abstract I still cannot see it.

OK, There were 115 men and 27% got success

Thus 115 x 0.27 = 31 successes
Therefore 115-31 = 84 failures, these must have failed on 250ug

Of these, 84 x 0.17 = 14 then succeeded on 500ug

Then 4 of 10 failing on 500ug subsequently succeeded on 1000ug

Thus the number succeeding overall is 4 + 14 + n = 31
n = 13, this must be the number succeeding on 250ug

But then 13 + 84 not equal to 115 (credit to lpmost on the yahoo thread for pointing this out).

So, can we get it by assuming that some men dropped out during the experiment and/or more than 115 started - I'll look? Weird abstract.

Sorry the balls up after shooting my mouth off - that'll teach me.

DaiS

*****
115 men aged 64.8ñ10.6 with regular sexual partner were treated in a manner patterned after the initial NEJM
report. They were in general well educated with 50.9%. college and 28.9% postgraduate education. Self rating of
genera health resulted in a mean of 8.1 (scare from 1-10), and of sexual function in a mean of 3.5 (1-10). Status
post prostatectomy and diabetes were the most common etiologies. In-office treatment with increasing doses of
MUSE were conducted with self-rating of penile rigidity (1-5, 4 and 5 being sufficient for intercourse) and level
of comfort (1-5) as well as blood pressure checks in 15 min intervals.

RESULTS:

Peak rigidities were achieved at 30 min with means of 2.6 (250 mcg), 2.4 (500 mcg), and 2.9 (1000 mcg). Only
27% of pts achieved rigidity sufficient for intercourse despite being challenged to the highest dose. Of those pts
who failed on 250 mcg, 17% achieved a level 4 or 5 with 500 mcg, and of those 10 failing on 500 mcg only 4
achieved such level with 1000 mcg. Discomfort was maximal at 15 min with means of 3.5 (250 mcg), 3.7 (500
mcg), and 4.2 (1000 mcg). Blood pressure decreased significantly at 15 and 30 min. and orthostatic hypotension
(decrease by >20 mmHg at 30 min) occurred in 6.%. Penile pain and burning with 41% each were the most
common adverse events, followed by dizziness (14%). There was no significant interaction between mean rigidity
scores and age or etiologies. Most disappointing is the fact that at follow-up only 18.6% of pts continue the use
of the MUSE system, while the majority have chosen alternative treatment forms, citing disappointment with the
results and cost as the most important reasons for dicontinuation




To: Frostman who wrote (9247)6/5/1998 8:23:00 PM
From: DaiS  Respond to of 23519
 
Frostman,

Panic over I hope.

It can work with 18 dropouts after step one, but it is not necessary to assume this.

This is the revised analysis. I made mistake to assume that because 27% or 31 men were successful then 115-31 = 84 men failed at the lowest dose. In fact more could fail.

Step 1: They took 115 men and tested with 250ug muse. They had 9 successes and 106 failures (8% success on 250ug muse)

Step 2: They tested the 106 failures with 500ug muse. They had 17% or 18 successes and 88 failures (20% success with up to and including 500ug muse)

Step 3: They then tested only 10 of these 88 failures with 1000ug muse. They had 4 successes and 6 failures (10/115 is 9% as in the Vivus press release)

An adjusted overall success rate for up to and including 1000ug muse can be obtained,

((9 + 18 + (4/10 x 88))/115 x 100 = 54%

Allowing dropouts there are a range of possibilitites including the one I posted earlier.

This above solution is obtained by solving the 3 simultaneous equations

4+x+y=31
x=0.17N
N+y=115

where, N becomes 106 above, x becomes 18 and y becomes 9.

If I made a mistake this time I will look a real fool, but it's bedtime now I'll check tomorrow.

DaiS