To: borb who wrote (1166 ) 6/18/1998 9:17:00 AM From: chirodoc Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 3902
"It's one thing for ambitious provisions to be announced, but quite another to prevent the civil service from eroding what's in it," -- Richard Farrell, Guinness Flight <Picture> <Picture> <Picture><Picture> Fund Watch Features: The Folks with the Bucks Aren't Buying into the Japan Recovery Story By Peter Eavis Senior Writer 6/17/98 8:48 PM ET <Picture>Nice try, Bob, but it'll take more to drag us back into Japan. That, in a nutshell, is the reaction of international fund managers to today's news that Robert Rubin spent a cool $2 billion dollars to prop up the yen. "We're not considering upping our Japan exposure at all," says Rob Reiner, co-manager on the BT Investments' International Equity, which had 4.6% of its assets in Japan at the end of March. "We've seen so many false starts before." The buysiders say the Japanese stock market simply has few promising companies. Yes, there may be a brief rally on the back of currency intervention news. But unless the country's politicians come up with a swinging reform package -- and actually implement it -- then Japan will continue to disappoint. "We're not taking any precipitous action to get into Japan," says George Evans, manager of the Oppenheimer International Growth, which has a 5% weighting in the country. "We want to see exactly what's going on before we do anything." The immediate reaction to the U.S. yen-buying was optimistic. The bulls are saying that Rubin, a smart cookie, would never have agreed to intervene in currency markets unless he had extracted cast-iron commitment from the Japanese for a sweeping program of structural reforms. And such a program is likely to include big tax cuts and a bank bailout and restructuring program similar to that carried out in the U.S. by the Resolution Trust Corporation. Any inkling that these are on their way would spark an almighty rally in the Nikkei. Longer term, it would prepare the ground for a resumption of economic growth. But to seasoned international managers, things aren't that simple. First, many of the necessary reforms could be destabilizing to the equity market. Any meaningful bailout would cost at least 82 trillion yen, or a massive 17.6% of 1997 GDP, which would cause a deterioration in Japan's already shaky fiscal position. In addition, to pay for a bailout, the government will have to print currency and raise some of the money by forcing the state-owned postal bank to sell some of its government bonds. Such actions are bound to cause more yen weakness and trigger more worries of further Asian devaluations. Some are wondering exactly how many concessions Rubin actually got. Maybe, they say, the intervention was done more to prevent a devaluation of the Chinese yuan, which was looking shakier with every dip in the dollar/yen rate. "This was probably done partly to reward China for not devaluing," says Reiner. One thing is clear: Any economic revival package would have to be much larger and deeper than previous ones to boost sentiment. "It must include an enormous tax cut," says Evans, who points out that even though Japan has introduced five stimulus packages in the last year or so, its economy is still deep in the doldrums. And a banking sector reform would have to be far-reaching and ruthless, says Paul Fraker, co-manager of the 59 Wall Street Pacific Basin fund, which has 83% of its assets in Japan. A straight bailout would not work unless some banks actually go bust. This has to happen to reduce the number of banks and increase the profitability of the survivors. "Only then will banks start lending again." Plans for a wide-ranging plan may well be announced in the coming weeks. But some fear that the infamously obstructive Japanese bureaucracy may water down such a plan. "It's one thing for ambitious provisions to be announced, but quite another to prevent the civil service from eroding what's in it," remarks Richard Farrell, manager of Guinness Flight's Asia Blue Chip fund. "I'm taking a wait-and-see approach." Sweeping policies may well get fully implemented this time. But even if they are, a lasting recovery largely depends on much deeper, almost cultural, changes taking place, says Charlie Lovejoy, manager of the Legg Mason International Equity fund. As well as a shake-up of the banking sector, he wants to see more competition, freer labor markets and a better environment for small to medium-sized companies. Managers may sound deeply skeptical. But they are not pessimists. They believe that Rubin's move is a promising signal that Japan may be about to turn a corner. "This is one of the best pieces of news we've had out of Asia since the crisis began," says Farrell. And Fraker says: "If the Japanese do the right thing, the Nikkei could finish the year above 20,000" says Paul Fraker. The index closed today at 14,715.