To: Joe C. who wrote (5289 ) 7/14/1998 1:21:00 AM From: Stuart C Hall Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 16960
I am by no means a 3D expert but I am willing to share my impressions on the ELSA link. From my understanding of ELSA their cards generally appear on Compaq, Dell and HP high end Workstations. These workstations are designed to compete with SGI and Sun boxes (isn't someone at TDFX an ex-SGI employee?). The graphics cards Dell and Compaq (also known as **OEMs**, get my point?) use on these workstations are specifically designed for certain CAD (Computer Aided Design) software packages. These are not your father's workstations. They are generally 10k plus and these cards are specifically made to accelerate these special CAD programs. I also believe in most cases they are proprietary. In other words, this 3D card will only work with this certain CAD program. (Does part of that paragraph jar the memory of how you explain to your friends that your TDFX card is dormant until you fire up a 3D acclerated game? I think there is a strong comparison to the CAD cards and the current 3D game market. However, TDFX is not proprietary to any certain game platform!) Whew! So, knowing that Banshee is being adopted by ELSA is a good thing. It makes a statement to OEM boxmakers that this high end OEM card maker is getting on the TDFX train. A while back there was debate on this thread about 3D's killer app. CAD is by no means our saviour. After all, this is 3D labs territory (shudders like the Hyenas in Lion King when they hear Mufasa's name). But, if TDFX can somehow generate support for themselves in the CAD area they have added another market in search of a reliable product without alienating their core audience. Addtionally, CAD guys are used to working with proprietary software (and hardware) and may find a GLIDE type program a blessing rather than a curse. I believe one of our fellow SI members wondered aloud why TDFX is not cleaning up in the 3D modeling light work of programs like Fractal Design's Poser. Personally, I believe this was below the capability of our noble chipset to address. Something juicy like honest 3D modeling might be worthy of bearing the Voodoo name. (Amazing how cocky I get after a 2 point jump ;-) Again, I am by no means an expert and this is all IMHO. All corrections or elaborations are welcome. No FUD intended. This all raises more questions in my mind. What is possessing ELSA to adopt Banshee, which is a game card, when they are known to be high end CAD pros? Has TDFX something up their sleeves in the form of an API for CAD users? Can anyone clear the air on ELSA as a company or further delve into their product line? Regards, Stuart (hey SI, I need a free membership!!) Hall