To: Phillip C. Lee who wrote (15855 ) 7/21/1998 10:45:00 AM From: soup Respond to of 213177
OT(?) Dell Valuation. Cribbed from Yahoo! AAPL RodgerRafter Jul 20 1998 7:46PM EDT >They gave Michael Dell a standing ovation at the shareholder's meeting last Friday. The stock has risen 2600% in the last 3 years. Someday Dell is going to give back all those gains. CEO Dell is a master of spin, hype and illusion. He drew cheers when he announced that the Dell online store was selling $6 million per day. However, he's counting phone orders as "on-line" orders. He also got cheers for predicting that overseas revenues would be up over $6 billion from $4.3 billion. Even if he's right (he isn't half way through the year yet) 40% would be a huge drop off from past revenue growth, in the region that is supposed to be providing their best growth. Suspiciously, nothing was mentioned about US growth prospects. With IBM's hardware sales down 12.7% in Q2, (PC sales getting most of the blame), and CPQ product sales down slightly, it seems Dell could have a lot to hide. It's hard to see Dell meeting this quarter's earnings estimates of 46 cents per share, which would be a projected 58% rise over last year. Nevertheless, they've got a few tricks that should hold up their share price. For one thing, the shareholders just increased the number of shares outstanding, so we can expect a split announcement with the earnigs, just as they did in February. Additionally, they can always cut costs like R&D spending or buy back an unlimited amount of shares to make EPS come out the way they want. 2 quarters ago, a surprise (unpublicized) drop in R&D spending (which was already the lowest in the industry by far) miraculously turned an earnings disappointment into an postive surprise. Profits are largely suspect because of the large amount of dilution caused by Dell's employee stock option grants (just about the largest around). They've also been shamelessly buying back stock, and I've watched in amazement as Price to Book has gone from 20 all the way up to 52 in the past 9 months. Instead of investing their profits in new plants and equipment to increase production, Dell now contracts out much of their production which hurts margins, quality control and the efficiency of their direct margins. Instead of developing new products or expanding through acquistions, Dell continues to just dilute/repurchase themselves until there isn't any book value left. Someday, the market is going to figure out that there just isn't any lasting substance left to Dell. It's all marketing, hype and accounting trickery. Until then, I'm staying out of the way. I already lost too much on Dell shorts back at the start of this year. Dell, IBM, that's two down. I'll bash Compaq when I get some more time. Until then... Go AAPL. Rodg.<