To: stsimon who wrote (63571 ) 8/29/1998 6:19:00 PM From: nihil Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 186894
RE: No action in Japan You wonder why Japan can sit in a 8 year slump despite long-term interest rates of <2% and short-term interest rates of < .5%. The answer is simple. Much of the economy is wrapped up in industrial groups (keiretsu). Most of these companies have excess capacity and are closing or moving operations over seas (Nissan shut down it's main plant a couple of years ago). Because of intergroup stock ownership, management can survive any loss or failure. These companies feel a deep sense of obligation to the country and also refuse to force the government to overthrow the bureaucrats in the Ministry of Finance and MITI. Nothing changes, and the government even imposes consumption taxes. There is enormous potential for public improvements (Tokyo could use a sewer system, f.i.). But debt and fear of inflation prevent the Keynesian solution to depression. Loans are available at very low rates to good credit risks. Banks and businesses borrow huge amounts and buy U.S. Treasuries with them. They earn over 5% on the bills and pay 1-3 per cent on the loans. (The collateral is usually Japanese paper, rather than the U.S. Treasuries). Really cautious people cover by selling dollars forward for yen at the maturity of the T bills (or buy yen forward for dollars -- same thing). This coverage reduces the return but eliminates exchange rate risk. It also reduces the downward pressure on the forward yen that would have occurred in uncovered trades. This whole process is called "the yen carry trade" and amounts to hundreds of billions. It has been going on for years, always at a profit. Risk for risk, a Japanese cannot find a better investment in Japan than he can find in the U.S. Alas, I cannot find a Japanese bank that will lend me a few trillion yen. This has had a considerable effect, maybe definitive, on the American bull market in stocks and bonds. As the U.S. has eliminated the deficit and the outstanding public debt has started to decrease the U.S. T bill yields have fallen, but are still profitable. A bizarre problem is the growing shortage of American debt instruments. The recent declines in the American stock market will make U.S. stocks even more attractive to the Japanese. With the Japan financial big bang Japanese savers will be bombarded by Japanese and (now) American stockbrokers and mutual fund salesmen. There $10 trillion on deposit in Japan earning less than .5% interest -- (about $80,000 per Japanase). This money is up for grabs (remember, the yen is falling faster than Japanese prices, deposits earn little and the real value of these savings is eroding.) I think money will tend move from Japan to the U.S. until interest rates and ROI in stocks are about equalized (a predicted result of the so-called H-O-S (Hecksher-Ohlin-Samuelson) Factor Price Equalization Theorem and the process is known as (covered) interest rate arbitrage. This makes me a bull on American stocks and bonds, and a continued bear on Japan stocks and bonds until they spend most of the $10 trillion on good American bonds and tech stocks.