To: Robert L. Ray who wrote (82 ) 9/25/1998 3:20:00 PM From: Robert L. Ray Respond to of 127
Orlistat/Xenical (Roche) news from Yahoodailynews.yahoo.com
Orlistat users still need to diet LONDON, Sep 25 (Reuters) -- Obese patients who take the drug orlistat will still have to diet in order to lose weight, according to a British nutritionist. Orlistat (Xenical), which was approved for sale in Europe last month, helps patients lose weight by causing 30% of dietary fat to be excreted in the feces, former professor of human nutrition John Garrow writes in an editorial in the September 26th issue of the British Medical Journal. But many obese patients will be surprised to discover that more than half of their eventual weight loss will be due to diet rather than to the drug, he says. Garrow notes that some media reports said that the drug would enable obese people to eat what they like and still lose weight. ''This is highly misleading,'' he writes. As reported by Reuters Health, a recent 2-year double-blind prospective trial of orlistat therapy showed that obese patients who took the drug lost more and regained less weight than patients given a placebo (inactive substance). Both groups were on hypocaloric diets that were 600 kcal below daily energy expenditure. Garrow comments that while the weight losses achieved by orlistat users were clinically significant, diet accounted for more than half of the reductions. Moreover, patients taking the drug will voluntarily reduce their fat in take in order to avoid side effects of the drug, including fatty stools, increased defecation, and oily spotting. ''Anyone taking orlistat who eats a high-fat diet will receive a powerful incentive to reduce fat intake,'' Garrow said, referring to these side effects. ''It will be ironic if this new drug succeeds by exactly the action which it was said not to have -- by inducing obese people to keep to a low-fat reducing diet,'' he adds. Garrow also writes that weight loss similar to that seen in studies of the drug are possible over 6 months ''if energy intake had been reduced by a similar amount; this is not impossible with well-supervised outpatient dieting.'' Orlistat has not been approved in the United States, but is currently undergoing review by the US Food and Drug Administration.