To: Kerm Yerman who wrote (12423 ) 9/23/1998 1:40:00 AM From: Kerm Yerman Respond to of 15196
IN THE NEWS / Resource Rebound On Canadian Stock Markets By DAVID THOMAS Economics Reporter The Financial Post Canada's previously battered resource stocks have stormed back with a vengeance this month, but analysts suspect the rally will be short lived. Commodity-related sectors rank as the top four in performance in the Toronto Stock Exchange 300 composite index in September. What's more, they account for all but one of the index's top 30 returning stocks and 73 of the top 80. But several portfolio managers say the surge is part of a short-term defensive rally and is unlikely to be sustained. They advise investors to remain cautious with most resource stocks, with the popular exceptions of those in the oil and gas sector. A lot of the recent bounce in gold, oil, metals and forestry stocks results from a perception the miserable performers could not fall any further, said Andrew Martyn, portfolio manager with Davis-Rea Ltd. Investment Counsel. "I think it's a bit of a hiding routine," said Martyn. Many institutional investors have to stay invested and the challenge during a selloff is to survive the storm, he explained. "When people really get clobbered, they start to look for value, rather than momentum. People ask: 'Where am I going to lose the least amount of money?' " For some traders the potential has been there to make a lot of money. While the broader TSE 300 has bounced back 5.3% from its low at the end of August, some of its subindexes have soared. The top performers are gold stocks (up 38%) and oil and gas stocks (up 21%). Trailing but still strong are metals and minerals (up 17.5%) and paper and forest products (up 10%). As a representative group, the 30 stocks that make up the resource subgroup of the TSE 100 index have rallied a little over 25% this month, nearly five times better than the broader market's gain. In another telling statistic, the 29 resource stocks among the TSE 300's top 30 performers this month have averaged a 46% advance. Martyn said trading in resource stocks remains thin and it hasn't taken much buying to get the battered prices on an upward roll. Despite the gains, the road back to respectability is also steep. The 52-week returns are still disastrous for golds (off 25.4%), oil and gas (off 30%), metals (off 38.4%) and paper and forest products (off 33.5%). Bob Boaz, a portfolio strategist with University Avenue Funds, joined Martyn in expecting this rally to fizzle, with the one possible exception - oil and gas stocks. Boaz sees the price of crude oil, which closed yesterday at US$15.67› a barrel in New York, headed back to the US$17 range. He said shareholders can look forward to stronger returns as profits improve. "Investors can get pretty significant returns if the oil market holds its value or goes higher." As for other resource sectors, Boaz said most of the buying has been based on the assumption stock prices can't go much lower. Gold stocks are vulnerable to a setback as bullion prices renew their long-term decline and base metals producers still have to contend with excess supply and slow global growth, he said. Thin trading volumes support the argument the surge in resource stocks is the result of bottom fishing by retail investors, rather than a change in sentiment among institutional money managers, he added. Meanwhile, few analysts are predicting a quick turnaround in commodity prices and some expect more weakness. Vincent L‚pine, senior economist at L‚vesque Beaubien Geoffrion Inc., is predicting another 5% decline in commodity prices, as measured by the CRB/Bridge index of commodity futures prices.