To: Dayuhan who wrote (13351 ) 10/8/1998 10:48:00 PM From: JF Quinnelly Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 71178
Has any communist organization overthrown a democracy? There haven't been many democracies in history, but of course I can name some. After 1918 Poland, Hungary, and Czechoslovakia were all free republics, and Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia were independent countries. All of them had communist regimes forced upon them following the Second World War, as did Germany which had been a democracy in the Weimar period. I'd have been disappointed if you hadn't restated the myths of the left, which never fail to blame someone else: encouraging and supporting right wing dictators creates exactly the conditions that left wing regimes require to grow. The US right, with its slavish support of Somoza, did far more to bring the Sandinistas to power than the Soviets. The American right has done far more damage than the American left, but only because it has had far more power. Do you deny that the nature of any opposition is shaped by the nature of the regime it opposes? I believe in free will and hold people accountable for their own actions, so I don't agree that they can pawn off their behavior on "the nature of the regime [they] oppose". It's one of the defining differences between right and left, in my opinion. Claiming that the American Right had more to do with the Sandanistas than the Soviets is really a stretch. Carlos Fonseca and Tomas Borge were active members of the Moscow-line Partido Socialista Nicaraguense back in the early '50s. Fonseca travelled to Moscow in 1957 and wrote an apology for the Soviet system on his return, A Nicaraguan in Moscow . An association with Castro began in 1959, and Fonseca moved permanently to Havana. In 1960 Fonseca, Borge, Silvio Mayorga, and Humberto Ortega founded the FSLN, naming it for Sandino. Ortega wrote that Marxist-Leninist theory was the basis of their organization. The connections and training of the FSLN by the Soviets and Cubans was extensively written up by people who left the FSLN. The lack of freedom in Sandanista Nicaragua was a natural product of Marxist-Leninist rule, just as it still is today in Cuba. When Castro dies, I'll look forward to all the glowing tributes that will paid to him. I wonder what end of the political spectrum the tributes will come from....