To: George J. Tromp who wrote (1373 ) 10/16/1998 6:02:00 PM From: Tomato Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 2251
I admit to knowing very little about figuring NPV, but the numbers posted by Maintenance on the WSP thread don't make a lot of sense to me. For one thing, isn't taking 10% as the discount rate very high in this interest rate environment? Aren't you supposed to use as a discount rate the risk free rate of return? Am I wrong on that? Anyway, here's a summary of the numbers from the scoping study, Maintenance's numbers, and my numbers. I wish somebody with an MBA or business background who knows of what he or she speaks would set us straight, since the there's a big difference between the $6 plus figure of Maintenance and the $31 number I come up with. BTW, I think I used 67% instead of 67.75% in my calculations of WSP's percentage interest. Scoping Study; Model 2: Assumes Combined Open pit and Underground Operation (Processing Rate = 1000 tonnes per day) Assumed Total Tonnage of Kimberlite Mined: 3,500,000 tonnes Mine Life 10 years Assumed Ore Value* $Can400 / tonne Assumed Diluted Ore Value $Can380.95 / tonne Assumed Total Capital Costs $Can 103.8 million Assumed Total Operating Costs Over Mine Life $Can 305.0 million Total Cash Flow (Assuming Current NWT Tax Structure) $Can 572.4 million Discounted Cash Flow Rate of Return (After Tax) 55.6% Maintenance Take: Assuming model 2 from MRDI, and assuming management , office and other overhead costs of $1,000,000 per year, and assuming 60% tax, and assuming 2 years to start production. Tons/year...............350000 Rev/ton....................400 Cost/ton....................87 Net/ton....................313 Gross margin.........109550000 fixed costs............1000000 Gross profit.........108550000 Tax...................65130000 Net...................43420000 Ten year life. Discounted at 10%.....227324376 Discounted 2 yrs......187871385.5 Startup cost..........103800000 NPV...................$84071385.5 NPV/Share..........$2.272199608 If you assume 2200 metres instead of 850, and all else equal, you may get 25 year life, or NPV/Share of $5.99, again at 10% To: VAUGHN (1306 ) From: Tomato Wednesday, Oct 7 1998 1:01PM ET Reply # of 1374 I was trying to figure out a value per share of WSP based on that David James report posted by VAUGHN. See if these figures check out.. In Situ Value: $400/tonne X 3.5 mil tonnes = $1,400mil Less $87/tonne operating costs - 304 Less capital costs - 104 Net value 991.5 WSP's 67% share 664 Divided by 37 mil shares fully diluted 17.95/sh or another way to do it... In Situ Value: $400/tonne X 3.5 mil tonnes = $1,400mil WSP share of 67% 938 Less 67% of $104m capital costs - 70 less 67% of $87/tonne operating costs -204 Net value 664 Divided by 37 mil shares 17.95 at 10 mil. tonnes, multiply by 3, or approx. $54/sh. Discount rate? What percent should one use? The current Fed. rate? 10% seems way too much. Don't you go with the risk free return? The figures on an old Yorkton report for Aber using 5% discount rate over 15 years go from $26.90 per share to $15.60 per share, a 42% reduction for current value. Subtract 42% from my $54 figure, and you get...$31.32/sh. If you want to subtract G&A from that...$15mil divided by 37 mil shares..40 cents per share off, or rounded off, $31 share. Add on to that something for Carat, Hilltop, and the possibility of a pipe under Snap Lake.